An Analysis of Preposition (Idiomatic Phrases, Prepositional Phrases and Zero Prepositions) Detection Errors in the Writing of Graduate ESL Learners of Pakistan

An Analysis of Preposition (Idiomatic Phrases, Prepositional Phrases and Zero Prepositions) Detection Errors in the Writing of Graduate ESL Learners of Pakistan

Muhammad Rizwan

Contact

Sumaira Akhtar

Contact

Waqas Sohail

Contact

An Analysis of Preposition (Idiomatic Phrases, Prepositional Phrases and Zero Prepositions) Detection Errors in the Writing of Graduate ESL Learners of Pakistan

Article Fingerprint

ReserarchID

TTT36

AI TAKEAWAY

Connecting with the Eternal Ground

Abstract

In this paper we describe a methodology for detecting preposition errors in the writing of ESL graduate learners. To investigate the nature of errors in the writing skill problems of graduate learners, two fifty graduate male and female learners randomly selected from four colleges and one university were asked to complete two writing skill tasks: Fifth word deletion and open composition test. The study is related to the research question: Why ESL graduate learners commit errors in their writing skills? (a) Prepositions, phrasal verbs and idiomatic phrases. It is detected that preposition overuse and preposition omission are the common problems for ESL. Besides, students deem prepositions quite tricky to use in their writing. So the findings show the wrong use of prepositions specifically ‘with, in, of’ and unnecessary insertion of prepositions. It is observed that errors are because of the interference of L1 in L2. Besides, the final results of the two tests showed that Prepositions (prepositional verbs, prepositional phrases, phrasal verbs, zero prepositions) are quite problematic for ESL learners. The learners try to put prepositions on the same patterns of L1 which ultimately leads them towards errors.

References

116 Cites in Article

Reference Format

H Abbas (1961). Al-Nahw Al-Wafi.
S Abney (1987). The English Noun Phrase in its Sentential Aspect.
F Agoi (2003). Grammar.
A Akhtar (1997). A communicative framework of English language teaching for tenth grade ESL students in Pakistan.
Al,Y Marrani (2009). A comparative and contrastive study of prepositions in Arabic and english language in India. Strength for Today and Bright Hope for Tomorrow.
R Bangert-Drowns,M Hurley,B Wilkinson (2004). The effects of school-based writing-to-learn interventions on academic achievement: A metaanalysis.
Ruba Bataineh,Rula Bataineh (2005). Apology strategies of Jordanian EFL university students.
A Belletti (1994). Agreement projections.
K Berdan (2006). Writing for a Change: Boasting literacy and learning through social action.
J Bertkua (1974). An analysis of English learner speech.
Francisco Betancourt,Marianne Phinney (1988). Sources of Writing Block in Bilingual Writers.
T Bhatia (1993). Punjabi: A cognitive-descriptive grammar.
P Boquist (2009). The second language acquisition of English prepositions.
D Brown (1994). Teaching by Principles: An interactive approach to language pedagogy.
H Brown (1980). Principles of language learning and teaching.
W Bryant (1984). Typical errors in English made by Japanese ESL students.
D Byrne (1979). Teaching writing skills.
L Calkins (1986). The art of teaching writing.
R Catalan (1996). Frequency and Variability in Errors in the Use of English Prepositions.
M Celce-Murcia,D Larsen-Freeman (1983). The Grammar Book: an ESL/EFL Teacher's Course.
M Celce-Murcia,D Larsen-Freeman (1999). The grammar book: An ESL/EFL teacher's course.
C Chaudron,K Parker (1990). Discourse markedness and structural markedness: The acquisition of English noun phrases.
Martin Chodorow,Joel Tetreault,Na-Rae Han (2007). Detection of grammatical errors involving prepositions.
N Chomsky (1981). Lectures on government and binding.
M Chowdhury (2003). International TESOL training and EFL context: The cultural disillusionment factor.
Arlene Clachar (1999). It’s not just cognition: the effect of emotion on multiple-level discourse processing in second-language writing.
V Cohen (1998). Getting the articles across: issues and teaching approaches of the English article system.
A Curzan,M Adams (2006). How English works: a linguistic introduction.
S Darus,K Subramaniam (2009). Error Analysis of the written English essays of secondary school students in Malaysia: A case study.
G Davidson (2007). How to punctuate.
S Dessouky (1990). Error analysis, a no-stop area of research: An analytical study of English verb and preposition errors in the written expression of Al-Azhar Students.
David Deterding,Andy Kirkpatrick (2006). Emerging South‐East Asian Englishes and intelligibility.
H Dulay,M Burt,S Krashen (1982). Language two.
M East,D Young (2007). Scoring L2 writing samples: Exploring the relative effectiveness of two different diagnostic methods.
J Edge (1989). Mistakes and correction.
S Eggins (2004). An introduction to systemic functional linguistics.
V Evans,A Tyler (2005). Applying cognitive linguistics to pedagogical grammar: The English prepositions of verticality.
A Fang (2000). A lexicalist approach towards the automatic determination for the syntactic functions of prepositional phrases.
J Fernandez (1994). Adquisición y uso de las preposiciones españolas por un francófono.
D Ferris (2002). Treatment of error in second language writing classes.
Dana Ferris (2003). Response To Student Writing.
K Fion (2005). The acquisition of English spatial prepositions by ESL learners.
Michael Gamon,Claudia Leacock,Chris Brockett,William Dolan,Jianfeng Gao,Dmitriy Belenko,Alexandre Klementiev (2008). Using Statistical Techniques and Web Search to Correct ESL Errors.
S Gass,L Selinker (2001). Second language acquisition: An introductory course.
S Gass,L Selinker (2008). Second language acquisition: An introductory course.
A Goldberg (1995). 2 Argument structure constructions.
Tara Goldstein (2001). Researching women’s language practices in multilingual workplaces.
B Goto (2002). Second language learners' theories on the use of English articles.
S Graham,K Harris (1993). Improving the writing of students with learning problems: Selfregulated strategy development.
Y Grodzinsky (1988). Syntactic representations in a grammatic aphasia: The case of prepositions.
R Hamdallah,Hanna Tushyeh (1988). A contrastive analysis of selected English and Arabic prepositions with pedagogical implications.
Na-Rae Han,Martin Chodorow,Claudia Leacock (2006). Detecting errors in English article usage by non-native speakers.
J Harris (1993). Introducing writing.
N Hashim (1996). English syntactic errors by Arabic speaking learners reviewed.
R Hayden (1956). Mastering American English: A handbook-workbook of essentials: Englewood Cliffs.
John Hedgcock,Natalie Lefkowitz (1994). Feedback on feedback: Assessing learner receptivity to teacher response in L2 composing.
Michael Hegarty (2005). A Feature-Based Syntax of Functional Categories.
J Hendrickson (1980). The treatment of error in written work.
C Huang (1982). Logical Relations in Chinese and the Theory of Grammar.
T Huebner (1985). System and variability in interlanguage syntax.
Thorn Huebner (1985). SYSTEM AND VARIABILITY IN INTERLANGUAGE SYNTAX.
Z Hussain,M Hanif,S Asif,A Rehman (2013). An error analysis of L2 writing at higher secondary level in Multan.
F Irmscher (1979). Teaching expository writing.
C James (1985). Contrastive Analysis.
Y Kachru (2006). Unknown Title.
C Kao (1999). An investigation into lexical, grammatical, and semantic errors in English compositions of college students in Taiwan.
R Kellogg (2001). Long-term working memory in text production.
N Kharma,A Hajjaj (1997). Errors in English among Arabic speakers.
M Kieffer,N Lesaux (2007). Breaking down words to build meaning: Morphology, vocabulary, and reading comprehension in the urban classroom.
Bernd Kortmann,Ekkehard König (1992). Categorial reanalysis: the case of deverbal prepositions.
J Lannen (1989). The writing process: A concise rhetoric.
D Lardiere (2009). Some thoughts on the contrastive analysis of features in second language acquisition.
S Lee (2005). How robust is in-class sustained silent reading: An SSR program for non-English majors.
A Mahboob,M Talaat (2008). English language teachers and teacher education in Pakistan.
D Washington (1992). PUBLICATIONS RECEIVED.
Michael Maratsos (1974). Preschool Children's Use of Definite and Indefinite Articles.
P Master (1987). The English article system: Acquisition, function and pedagogy.
P Master (1994). The effect of systematic instruction on learning the English article system.
P Mathews (1997). Concise dictionary of linguistics.
Tom Mcarthur,Jacqueline Lam-Mcarthur,Lise Fontaine (1992). The Oxford Companion to the English Language.
D Mccutchen,P Teske,C Bankston (2008). Writing and cognition: Implications of the cognitive architecture for learning to write and writing to learn.
Handbook of writing research.
D Murray (1985). A writer teaches writing.
R Nickerson,D Perkins,E Smith (1985). The teaching of thinking.
J Norrish (1983). Language learners and their errors.
D Nunan (1999). Second language teaching and learning.
John Oller,Seid Ziahosseiny (1970). THE CONTRASTIVE ANALYSIS HYPOTHESIS AND SPELLING ERRORS.
R Onike (2007). Analysis of errors of prepositions of the learners' use of English in second language situation.
B Parrish (1987). A new look at methodologies in the study of article acquisition for learners of ESL.
J Pollock (1989). Verb movement, universal grammar and the structure of IP.
M Radwan (1988). A linguistic analysis of the grammatical and lexical errors in the nominal group found in the written English of Syrian University Students.
Jack Richards,Richard Schmidt (2002). Longman Dictionary of Language Teaching and Applied Linguistics.
Jack Richards (1980). Second Language Acquisition: Error Analysis.
J C Richards,J Plott,H Platt (1996). Dictionary of language teaching and applied linguistics.
W Rutherford (1987). Second language grammar: learning and teaching.
R Schafer,J De-Villiers (2000). Q&A: What Can Indigenous People Tell Us About Climate Change?.
D Schiffrin (1994). Approaches to discourse.
R Schmidt (1999). Urdu: An essential grammar.
M Scott,G Tucker (1974). Error analysis and English-language strategies of Arab students.
R Shapira (1978). The non Learning of English: Case study of an adult.
S Siddiqui (2007). Rethinking education in Pakistan: Perceptions, practices, and possibilities.
B Sudhakaran (2008). The use of prepositions among Malay adult ESL Learners.
M Thahir (1987). INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON CAMPUS MAPS.
Margaret Thomas (1989). The acquisition of English articles by first- and second-language learners.
M Tremblay (1996). Lexical and non-lexical prepositions in French.
Jenine Turner,Eugene Charniak (2007). Language modeling for determiner selection.
H Ura (2001). Case.
W Walker (1655). A treatise of English particles.
J Warriner,F Griffith (1977). Warriner's English grammar and composition.
S Weigle (2002). Assessing writing.
H Widdowson (1979). Explorations in applied linguistics.
X Xi,P Mollaun (2006). Investigating the utility of analytic scoring for the TOEFL academic speaking test.
Keumsil Yoon (1993). CHALLENGING PROTOTYPE DESCRIPTIONS: PERCEPTION OF NOUN COUNTABILITY AND INDEFINITE VS. ZERO ARTICLE USE.
R Yopp,H Yopp (2007). Ten important words plus: A strategy for building word knowledge.
G Yule (1996). Pragmatics.
M Zoghoul (1979). Teaching English creatively.

Download References

Funding

No external funding was declared for this work.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Ethical Approval

No ethics committee approval was required for this article type.

Data Availability

Not applicable for this article.

How to Cite This Article

Muhammad Rizwan. 2017. \u201cAn Analysis of Preposition (Idiomatic Phrases, Prepositional Phrases and Zero Prepositions) Detection Errors in the Writing of Graduate ESL Learners of Pakistan\u201d. Global Journal of Human-Social Science - G: Linguistics & Education GJHSS-G Volume 17 (GJHSS Volume 17 Issue G2): .

More Citation Formats

Select Citation Style:

Download Citation

Download Article

GJHSS Volume 17 Issue G2
Pg. 45- 63

Explore Journals Explore Volume Read This Issue

Journal Specifications

Crossref Journal DOI 10.17406/GJHSS

Print ISSN 0975-587X

e-ISSN 2249-460X

Keywords

Not Found

Classification

GJHSS-G Classification: FOR Code: 930199

Submission ReceivedDecember 8, 2016
Peer Review Double Blind
Handling Editor
Accepted December 31, 2016
Published January 15, 2017

Version of record

v1.2

Issue date

March 22, 2017

Language

Experiance in AR

Explore published articles in an immersive Augmented Reality environment. Our platform converts research papers into interactive 3D books, allowing readers to view and interact with content using AR and VR compatible devices.

View in VR

Read in 3D

Your published article is automatically converted into a realistic 3D book. Flip through pages and read research papers in a more engaging and interactive format.

View in 3D

Article Matrices

Total Score: 103

Country: Pakistan

Subject: Global Journal of Human-Social Science - G: Linguistics & Education

Authors: Muhammad Rizwan, Sumaira Akhtar, Waqas Sohail (PhD/Dr. count: 0)

View Count (all-time): 162

Total Views (Real + Logic): 3722

Total Downloads (simulated): 1733

Publish Date: 2017 03, Wed

Monthly Totals (Real + Logic):

Month 1: 56 views
Month 2: 67 views
Month 3: 28 views
Month 4: 35 views
Month 5: 27 views
Month 6: 46 views
Month 7: 32 views
Month 8: 40 views
Month 9: 40 views
Month 10: 29 views
Month 11: 25 views
Month 12: 25 views
Month 13: 22 views
Month 14: 43 views
Month 15: 37 views
Month 16: 29 views
Month 17: 29 views
Month 18: 38 views
Month 19: 44 views
Month 20: 48 views
Month 21: 27 views
Month 22: 33 views
Month 23: 26 views
Month 24: 30 views
Month 25: 28 views
Month 26: 46 views
Month 27: 34 views
Month 28: 15 views
Month 29: 26 views
Month 30: 28 views
Month 31: 17 views
Month 32: 42 views
Month 33: 49 views
Month 34: 39 views
Month 35: 30 views
Month 36: 32 views
Month 37: 40 views
Month 38: 40 views
Month 39: 28 views
Month 40: 26 views
Month 41: 29 views
Month 42: 29 views
Month 43: 34 views
Month 44: 27 views
Month 45: 23 views
Month 46: 34 views
Month 47: 29 views
Month 48: 34 views
Month 49: 31 views
Month 50: 42 views
Month 51: 38 views
Month 52: 33 views
Month 53: 39 views
Month 54: 22 views
Month 55: 35 views
Month 56: 18 views
Month 57: 17 views
Month 58: 20 views
Month 59: 43 views
Month 60: 40 views
Month 61: 41 views
Month 62: 30 views
Month 63: 35 views
Month 64: 45 views
Month 65: 19 views
Month 66: 25 views
Month 67: 22 views
Month 68: 11 views
Month 69: 49 views
Month 70: 38 views
Month 71: 44 views
Month 72: 35 views
Month 73: 45 views
Month 74: 32 views
Month 75: 36 views
Month 76: 21 views
Month 77: 39 views
Month 78: 25 views
Month 79: 25 views
Month 80: 39 views
Month 81: 34 views
Month 82: 28 views
Month 83: 36 views
Month 84: 27 views
Month 85: 44 views
Month 86: 31 views
Month 87: 42 views
Month 88: 27 views
Month 89: 31 views
Month 90: 32 views
Month 91: 30 views
Month 92: 15 views
Month 93: 22 views
Month 94: 22 views
Month 95: 42 views
Month 96: 30 views
Month 97: 16 views
Month 98: 29 views
Month 99: 45 views
Month 100: 27 views
Month 101: 14 views
Month 102: 21 views
Month 103: 35 views
Month 104: 46 views
Month 105: 47 views
Month 106: 47 views
Month 107: 49 views
Month 108: 36 views
Month 109: 49 views

Total Views: 3722

Total Downloads: 1733

2026 Trends

Published Article

Our website is actively being updated, and changes may occur frequently. Please clear your browser cache if needed. For feedback or error reporting, please email [email protected]