This article provides a comparative legal analysis of the level and mechanisms of social security for migrant workers in Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan. It demonstrates that national models for regulating labour migration in the region focus on access to the labour market, organised employment and the protection of labour rights, whereas migrants’ pension, healthcare and insurance rights are determined primarily by the law of the country of employment and by treaty-based coordination. Four types of legal regimes are identified: an integration-based regime (Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan as members of the Eurasian Economic Union, EAEU); a bilateral treaty-based regime (Tajikistan); a regime of state support for organised migration with limited treaty coordination (Uzbekistan); and a regime characterised by a minimum degree of publicly ascertainable legal certainty (Turkmenistan). Particular attention is paid to the CIS Agreement on the Provision of Medical Assistance to Citizens of CIS Member States of 27 March 1997 and the Agreement on Mutual Recognition of Rights to Compensation for Damage Caused by Injury to, or Other Harm to the Health of, Workers of 9 September 1994. The study establishes that the weakest element remains the portability of social rights, including recognition of insurance periods, the granting and payment of pensions after return, and family members’ access to healthcare. Proposals for harmonising legislation are substantiated: a model regional standard of social guarantees, digital recording of insurance periods and contributions, expansion of the treaty network, and regulation of the position of informally employed and seasonal migrants.