When Zhanna Antonovna took her first steps in science, the study of migration was still in its infancy and was a semi-prohibited subject. Thanks to her talent and decades of dedicated work, the basic framework of migration studies in Russia was established.
Vladimir Shkolnikov.
My personal impression of Zhanna Antonovna is of a fresh breeze, sometimes a little whirlwind,
but never destructive, only invigorating; someone always ready for action,
without any of the solemn self-importance associated with age and academic authority...
Maria Savoskul.
1. Poltava. Family
Zhanna Antonovna Zaionchkovskaya was born on 28 May 1939 in Poltava, a newly established regional capital (the region had been created in 1937) with a population of 128,000. The Poltava-Kyiv dialect is regarded as the basis of standard literary Ukrainian.
Her mother, Matryona Ivanovna Zaionchkovskaya (née Lugovaya), was Ukrainian and came from a family of Cossack peasants; she worked in a department store. Her father, Anton Nartsissovich Zaionchkovsky, was a Pole from Kamianets-Podilskyi who had worked at a distillery before joining the army. Because of the charming, almost imperceptible Polish lilt in his wife’s speech, her husband Viktor Ivanovich Perevedentsev affectionately called her “pani” throughout their life together. She had no brothers or sisters of her own, but had eight cousins, only one of whom was a boy. Zhanka loved them all as siblings.
Her parents lived in their own house at 70 Oktyabrskaya Street. Her father was called up before the war and sent to a school for military interpreters. He was an officer, a captain, fluent in several languages, including German.
At the very beginning of the war, a death notice arrived saying he had been killed. Then a letter came from him saying he was alive. Thus, when a second death notice arrived after Poltava was liberated, her mother continued for a long time to hope that her husband would reappear.
When Zhanna Antonovna married, she did not take her husband’s surname, but retained her father’s, in the vague hope that this would make it easier for him to find her and her mother. Or perhaps relatives might turn up and recognize the name. She even visited her father’s hometown, Kamianets-Podilskyi, and tried to find something in the archives. She obtained the telephone numbers of all the Zaionchkovskys and called several of them, only to be told unanimously that there were whole villages of Zaionchkovskys in Podolia and that she could not hope to trace Anton Nartsissovich in this way. It is, after all, a very common Polish surname, the Russian equivalent being Zaitsev, derived from the word for “hare”: hop around and search!
But this time her father did not come back from the dead, and the second death notice had to be believed.
In the 2020s, with the help of archivist friends, she managed to obtain from the Central Archive of the Russian Ministry of Defence in Podolsk a certificate recording his death in 1943 in the Zaporizhzhia region. Attached was a note from inhabitants of the village near which he had died: “Dear parents, we are writing to tell you that your son has been killed. We saw him after the battle; he lay in the weeds for a month, then we took his documents and buried him, so do not expect him back. He was killed at the Vesyoloye state farm in the Vesyoloye district of Zaporizhzhia region.”
These documents deeply moved Zhanna Antonovna, who, according to her daughter, visited that far-from-cheerful place called Vesyoloye, the site of her father’s death1.
...In 1946, Matryona Ivanovna married again, this time to Grigory Pavlovich Kosmin, and they were given a room. They lived together without formally registering the marriage, seeing no need for it. Only in old age, at Zhanna Antonovna’s insistence, when she was considering bringing them to Moscow, did they go to the civil registry office in Poltava to marry officially. When they entered the building and found the right office, something extraordinary happened: as they walked into the room, her mother suddenly burst into tears! It turned out that the registry office occupied the very house in which they had lived before the war. The room in which they had come to register their marriage was the Zaionchkovskys’ own prewar room. Standing there, her mother vividly remembered everything, even where her daughter’s little bed had stood. What a story!
Grigory Pavlovich proved to be a gentle and kind man. Zhanna never called him her stepfather, only “Papa” or “Father.”
Neither he nor Matryona Ivanovna had been able to complete even secondary school because of the Holodomor or the war. This explained their determination to do everything possible to ensure that Zhanka received a proper, uninterrupted education. They paid for her school trip to Moscow in 1954 (only five families in that enormous school could afford to do so) and supported their daughter’s “whim” of studying not just anywhere but at Moscow State University itself!
2. Rybtsy. A Childhood under Occupation
Zhanka Zaionchkovskaya left us wonderful recollections of the German occupation, published in 20102.
She was barely two years old when war reached Poltava in August 1941. It was impossible to feed oneself in the city, so mother and daughter moved to Rybtsy, a large village close by3, where her mother’s parents, Ivan Gavrilovich and Irina Yakovlevna (Oryna Yakivna) Lugovoy, lived. Her mother’s four other sisters also came there with all their children.
But Rybtsy had its own misfortune: it stood right next to the Poltava military airfield, one of the largest in the USSR. The family therefore often went to spend the night in another village, Zhuki, five kilometres away. The smallest little cousins were taken in a handcart, while Zhanka, as the eldest (almost three years old already, just imagine!), had to walk the whole distance. From that time onward, she considered herself not just the eldest but the leader. Whenever the sisters and their little brother went somewhere together, the three-year-old commanded: “Little ones, follow me!”
One day, returning to Rybtsy, they found their cottage partly destroyed: a bomb had struck one corner of the house. A Christmas-tree ornament, the star placed on the very top of the tree, had fallen out of an overturned cupboard. Seeing such beauty, Zhanka hugged the star to herself and even lay on top of it, shielding it so that the adults could not take it away.
Children’s memories of occupation are especially vivid. They register things an adult’s consciousness and memory may simply fail to notice or distinguish. For instance, the “sweet table” of the occupation consisted of dried slices of sugar beet or processed molasses. To obtain a little jar of sweet Lend-Lease confectionery as “medicine,” Zhanka would have been ready to lie not merely on the floor but on ice and fall ill! Would an adult have done anything like that?
The little girl’s memory, together with the adults’ stories that had become deeply imprinted on her mind, preserved details that the grown-ups themselves had quickly and happily forgotten. One example was the mass baptism of young children in Ukraine before the Germans arrived, undertaken in the hope of protecting them from a supposedly imminent extermination. No such generalized threat existed, but the origin of the rumour is understandable: echoes of the hunting down and murder of Jews. Conversion, incidentally, did not save Jews: the killers were interested not in religious affiliation but in ethnic origin.
It seems amusing4 that after the war the first thing the adults did was remove the children’s crosses, because wearing them had now become dangerous! They were even forbidden to embroider in cross-stitch, since the cross was a religious symbol!
Yet the chances of a child dying under occupation, even a non-Jewish child, could hardly be called small. The dangers were the same as those faced by adults, while a little body had far less resistance.
War, like litmus paper, revealed everyone’s true nature: some rescued others, while others denounced them. Zhanna Antonovna spoke with disgust of a neighbour in Poltava who reported her mother as the wife of a communist, doing so, she said, “to take over our shed and appropriate the sunflower husks.”
Again the theme of food: flatbreads made from collective-farm millet stolen from the Germans were an unforgettable feast! What spells disaster for adults can sometimes bring children delight. They loved to crawl under the table and huddle around the smoky little lamp placed there during the blackout, enchanted by “the mystery of the darkness lit by a faint, flickering light.”
And here is a child’s observation of the gendered experience of hunger: “I think adolescent boys found it harder to bear hunger than girls. At any rate, I do not remember girls begging, while the boys were simply exhausted.” (Zaionchkovskaya, 2010, p. 136)
The end of the occupation remained in the child’s memory as a time of dreadful drinking among the surviving old men: they drank in bouts to relieve the stress they had endured. From time to time, explosions thundered near the airfield when teenagers stepped on mines left by the Germans.
On the whole, these recollections are filled with a child’s affirmation of life and optimism: “Life was hard, and the echoes of war lingered for a long time, but changes for the better could also be felt. Children felt them particularly keenly. For us, unfamiliar with many ordinary things, every novelty was a joy. For example, in first grade hardly anyone had coloured pencils, but by second grade almost everyone had a box of six, and some even had twelve, to everyone else’s envy. Later it became easy to buy boxes of twelve. [...] There were still long queues for bread, but now for white bread. In spite of everything, childhood was full of happy events.”
Notice the phrase “There were still long queues for bread, but now for white bread.” It already contains the whole character of the person who said it: attentiveness, tenacity, sharpness and analytical insight!
And here is the beginning of school: there were two first-grade classes, each with about eighty (sic!) pupils:
“And then came the first lesson, roll call. Nastasya Antonovna gets to know the children. She asks a girl her first and last name, then her mother’s name. The children answer. Next the teacher asks:
‘And your father?’
Suddenly the girl grows solemn, stands rigidly straight with her little hands pressed to her sides, and replies in a hollow voice:
‘Killed...’
And so it goes for almost the whole class, including me:
‘Killed...’
‘Killed...’
Even now my throat tightens when I remember it.”
The reader’s throat tightens too.
Zhanna Antonovna’s generation rarely told their own children about such experiences, and then only sparingly, following the healthy instinct for survival under an unhealthy regime: say nothing unnecessary! But as the Soviet dictatorship weakened, the taboo weakened with it, as did the syndrome of the sewn-up mouth.
3. Moscow. The Geography Faculty
In 1954, fifteen-year-old Zhanka visited Moscow on a school excursion with a group of eighth- and ninth-graders. Ten days in the capital!
The Mausoleum, the metro, the park of culture, the Udarnik cinema, the Tretyakov Gallery, the Exhibition of Achievements of the National Economy, even a bathhouse: absolutely everything amazed her! Most breathtaking of all, however, was the university on the Lenin Hills. The bus approached it from the Kaluga Gate across what was almost a wasteland. The sight of that many-towered castle against the sky and clouds was spellbinding! They were taken inside as well, shown the temple of learning from within, given a ride in the lift and perhaps even shown the Museum of Earth Science on the upper floors of the central tower.
It was then that the thought struck her: “That’s it! I’ll finish school with a gold medal and study here!” And that is precisely what happened. In 1956 she graduated with a gold medal from Ukrainian Secondary School No. 5 in Poltava, overcame the resistance of her parents and well-wishers, and travelled to Moscow to apply to Moscow State University. An outstanding school-leaver from the provinces chose not the local university in Poltava, nor the regional one in Kharkiv, but Lomonosov Moscow State University. And what faculty did she choose? Mechanics and Mathematics, the legendary Mekhmat, then the most prestigious and central of them all!
As a gold-medal graduate she only needed to pass an interview. But she had no idea, or rather did not know, what an interview for Mekhmat meant. She imagined they would probably ask her about life and ordinary things. In fact the interview was essentially an assay of the gold medal, a demanding mathematics examination. When she discovered this, she was so frightened that she went without sleep for three nights preparing. At the interview itself she was so sleep-deprived that she could not think at all; in a calm state she would have solved every problem.
Zhanka failed the interview. She was told she could take the regular entrance examinations along with the silver-medal winners if she wished. But she did not want to risk another failure and the final destruction of her dream. She would have gone home, had it not been for Larisa, a fellow resident in the hostel, a young teacher and another applicant: “Studying at MSU is a blessing in itself! Don’t panic: apply to another faculty!”
Only three faculties were still accepting applications for one more day: geography, biology and geology. Zhanna yielded to the persuasion and applied to geography. There was an interview there as well; she passed it calmly, and that was how she entered the Geography Faculty!5
For her first two years she studied in the Department of Meteorology and Climatology, one of the two most popular departments at the faculty (the other was Cartography), but also one of the hardest. She simply did not understand half the department names! After stumbling over Latin terminology, she acquired a dictionary of foreign words.
There were no hostel places left for her. During her first year she and another girl rented a room with one bed in a private house near Danilovsky Market. In her second year she was allowed to move into a hostel room and sleep on a camp bed. There were other girls already in the room, but they were nice girls, and everyone took a turn on the camp bed, a couple of months at a time. In her third year she finally received a proper room in the hostel.
In her second year, just before New Year 1958, another event transformed the world of the eighteen-year-old from Poltava. At a New Year’s party a fourth-year student invited her to dance, a Muscovite ten years her senior, aged twenty-eight. It was Viktor Perevedentsev, or “Viktór,” as his name was pronounced with the stress on the second syllable, emphasizing his leadership role.
They met, and within a couple of months, without a shadow of doubt, Zhanna and Viktór were officially married! They did not tell the family in Poltava, however, lest they think she had abandoned her studies.
Her bridegroom was so much older because he had spent a long time earnestly searching for himself and his calling. He had abandoned two technical colleges (though he completed a third) and one institute before finding himself at MSU’s Geography Faculty, which he entered in 1953 at the venerable age of twenty-two. He found his vocation in the Department of Economic Geography of the USSR6, where, under Sergei Alexandrovich Kovalev (1912-1987), a specialist in rural populations, he began studying migration. At the time only one other scholar in the whole country was seriously studying migration, Vadim Vyacheslavovich Pokshishevsky (1905-1984), whose focus, unlike Perevedentsev’s contemporary concerns, was historical-geographical retrospect7. Perevedentsev, an anthropogeographer by instinct, embraced the discipline’s credo: “Man is the measure of all things and the most interesting thing on earth!”
Zhanna spent two years studying meteorology. During her first university summer she went for three whole months to the Pamirs, on an International Geophysical Year expedition that followed the Pamir Highway from Osh to Murghab, rarely dropping below 4,000 metres above sea level.
Meanwhile, already in her second year, Perevedentsev had drawn his young wife deeply into “his” subject of migration. Notice how both their surnames suggest restlessness, mobility, migration: Zaionchkovskaya evokes a little hare hopping about, while Perevedentsev suggests a transfer from one place to another, a move.
During his graduation fieldwork in the Altai, studying the results of resettlement on virgin lands, Perevedentsev “discovered” the migration-statistics tables known as “Form No. 1,” and became enthralled by the blank forms and the data they contained. Back in Moscow, he copied the forms for every region of Western Siberia for several years. Zhanna, still only a second-year student, helped him calculate the figures for his graduation thesis. The result was sensational: Siberia was losing population! Not so much doubting the findings as obeying his instinct for self-preservation, Associate Professor Kovalev consigned the thesis to the restricted-access collection.
At the end of her second year Zhanna transferred to her husband’s department, which required another feat: passing all examinations in both departments, Meteorology and Economic Geography. And she passed them!
Zaionchkovskaya’s first course paper, in her second year, was devoted to V. V. Dokuchaev. From her third year onward she wrote her course papers and graduation thesis exclusively on migration. In her third year she studied Moscow and its surrounding region: “An Attempt to Study Contemporary Migration Links among Urban Settlements Using Current Population Registration Data (the Example of the Urban-Type Settlement of Dzerzhinsky).” She exposed the ineffectiveness of measures limiting residence registration in the city: within a year the flow of people to the capital had only increased8.
Her fourth-year paper was a monographic portrait of population formation in a young, isolated settlement beside a molybdenum plant in Khakassia. Its first workers were prisoners and those conditionally released, later joined by “Banderites,” or more precisely members of their families.
Her graduation thesis offered a detailed analysis, broken down by towns and districts, of migration links across the enormous Krasnoyarsk Territory9. Its original methodology for studying migration was later incorporated into a student textbook10. The exceptionally rich primary material was collected from the Resettlement Directorate of the Krasnoyarsk Territorial Executive Committee. The director, Ivan Illarionovich Shtromilo, an elderly Komsomol veteran who had stormed the Winter Palace in 1917 and served a long prison sentence after his arrest in 1937, supported her topic and work. All the material she requested was provided without delay. When her book appeared and Zhanna Antonovna took him a copy at home (Shtromilo had become frail and no longer worked), the old man wept with surprise and joy.
As for Perevedentsev, her principal teacher at the Geography Faculty was the aforementioned extremely cautious Kovalev, who in turn never tired of admiring the logic of her later work. Another vivid memory was Yulian Glebovich Saushkin (1911-1982), their department head and a brilliant professor and orator. She also remembered a small optional course taught by Mikhail Yakovlevich Sonin (1910-1984), the USSR’s leading specialist on labour resources, a courageous, open-minded man who defended a sober view of reality. He was capable, for instance, of taking the student Zaionchkovskaya to a meeting at Gosplan, passing her off as his secretary.
Let us also recall another teacher, whose name can no longer be recovered. During one lecture he reproached his students because none of them had attended Dmitri Shostakovich’s concert at the university’s House of Culture: “Mark my words: one day you will be proud to have lived at the same time as Shostakovich.” In the provincial girl who had once rushed to save a Christmas-tree star, this rebuke planted an interest in culture that later became a necessity and accompanied Zhanna Antonovna, a true Russian intellectual, all her life.
4. Moscow to Novosibirsk. Viktór
Let us take a closer look at the most important person in Zhanna Antonovna’s life: Viktor Ivanovich Perevedentsev (hereafter sometimes V. P.)11.
A geographer by education, a romantic by temperament, a natural democrat by conviction, a demographer and sociologist by profession, a publicist by disposition, an educator and journalist by vocation! At the transition from Soviet to Russian journalism, his name was associated with an entire era!
He is said to have been born on 3 January 1931, but in fact he was born in 1930, half an hour before the beginning of 1931. His mother registered his birth a couple of days later to postpone military service by a year12. He was born in the village of Ryazantsevo, Arsenyev district, Tula region, and his very birth brought him close to the subject of migration. His father, Ivan Vasilyevich Perevedentsev, came from a peasant family and was a seasonal migrant worker in Moscow, including as a carpenter on the metro construction project. Wounded near Stalingrad in 1943, he died in 1947. His mother was a native Muscovite, but after marrying in 1918 she moved to the village to live with her husband’s parents.
V. P.’s own “migration history” is reflected in the jobs and courses of study he tried before entering MSU: milling-machine operator at a Moscow aircraft factory, geophysical technician in Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan, and student at the Moscow Architectural and Construction Technical College, the Moscow Geophysical School of the Ministry of the Petroleum Industry, and the Baku Industrial Institute. Clearly he made extensive use of trial and error in finding himself. All the more brilliant, then, was his choice of wife!
V. P.’s academic career began while he was still a student: his graduation thesis already foreshadowed major discoveries in economic and social geography that he would later develop fully in his dissertation.
In 1958, after graduating, he went to Novosibirsk on an individual request under the Soviet job-allocation system. The Siberian Branch of the Academy of Sciences was being organized, Akademgorodok was under construction, and the 1959 population census was approaching (the previous one had taken place long before the war, in 1939). In Siberia he expected to study what he wanted, namely his beloved migration, including fieldwork and fresh census data. Remaining in Moscow, as he saw it, would mean a minor job as a laboratory assistant and research on whatever he was ordered to do. No, no, and once again no: such a “career” was not for Viktór!
Perevedentsev was personally invited to Novosibirsk by Georgy Alexandrovich Prudensky (1904-1967), a corresponding member of the USSR Academy of Sciences and founding director of the renowned Institute of Economics and Organization of Industrial Production (IEOIP) of the Siberian Branch. The Prudenskys and the Perevedentsev-Zaionchkovskaya family developed a personal friendship: the former repeatedly invited the latter to their detached cottage in Akademgorodok. They were also friends with Tatyana Zaslavskaya, Rozalina Ryvkina, Mikhail Sonin and others.
While working at IEOIP, Perevedentsev was also an external postgraduate student at the Academy of Sciences’ Institute of Economics in Moscow. In 1963, in his fifth year of Siberian research, he defended his Candidate of Sciences dissertation, “Contemporary Population Migration in Siberia.”13 Despite its title, this was by no means merely an ad hoc regional study14. More precisely, it was that as well, but it also had substantial methodological and theoretical dimensions15.
The loudest, even sensational, part was the empirical content, which called for an all-Union rather than regional scale of analysis. Perevedentsev was the first to establish that, contrary to all official aspirations and reports, the population of Siberia and the Far East was not growing in the postwar years but shrinking, owing to labour turnover and migration outflows to the USSR’s western and southern regions. These findings underpinned an analytical memorandum to the State Committee for Labour and Wages in which he proposed differentiated wage coefficients, the so-called “northern supplements” and “regional coefficients,” to encourage the eastward movement of people desired by the state.
Perevedentsev’s overall contribution to the study of population migration in the USSR is invaluable. He was among those who revived a field that had fallen into near-hibernation by the 1950s because of the lack of published statistics and the scarcity of accessible restricted data. His earliest works already lifted part of the veil concealing the real situation and prompted broader research into the territorial differentiation and mobility of the population.
V. P. spent about nine years in Novosibirsk, leaving Siberia’s capital only in 1967, shortly after Prudensky’s death and the subsequent change of direction at the institute he had founded, from regional studies to the mathematical methods then coming into fashion.
Before his wife arrived, V. P. lived in a hostel. Soon after her arrival, they were allocated an entire room in a two-room apartment: sheer luxury! Following his dissertation defence, they received a whole two-room apartment, and after their daughter’s birth, a three-room one.
5. Novosibirsk. New Settlers in Akademgorodok
While Perevedentsev enjoyed the coveted scientific freedom in Siberia without which science is impossible, Zaionchkovskaya continued her studies at the Geography Faculty. Viktor frequently visited Moscow to see his parents and newspaper editors, having already begun writing journalism and opinion pieces. Zhanna also came to Novosibirsk twice for summer practical training.
Those two-month field placements remained among her most vivid memories. She travelled alone around Siberian villages conducting surveys and, like Viktor, experienced genuine freedom and independence for the first time. She spent nights in district-centre inns known as “Collective Farmer’s Houses” and travelled to the villages she needed by bus or hitching rides.
Once, still a student, she approached a district official and asked for the data she needed, but he flatly refused. Zhanna then telephoned the institute’s leadership, which instructed the official from Novosibirsk to hand it over. As he opened his safe and took out folders marked “For Official Use,” he told her that he had been sentenced to ten years’ imprisonment in 1937 for precisely that sort of “violation.”
These student placements were supervised by Lev Vsevolodovich Starodubsky (1911-1987), who would also mentor her dissertation. Zhanna Antonovna recalled him and those placements in these words: “We had to draw up labour-resource balances for towns and rural districts. Lev Vsevolodovich’s credo was to send students out alone; only then, he believed, would they learn independence. The students were dispersed to different locations, though not too far apart, and each was responsible for an ’object’ of study. In any case, the experience of working without supervision, including having to account personally for every figure in the report (and he was a strict examiner!), lasted me a lifetime.”
In 1961, after finally graduating from MSU, Zhanna herself moved to join her husband in Siberia, the very place that had been used for centuries in Russia to frighten ordinary people. There was not a trace of the “Decembrist’s wife” or of cultivated Komsomol “self-sacrifice” in her decision. Quite simply, she found life there, and with him, genuinely interesting, increasingly so as time went on. She would have flown to the Moon if only a fair planet-wide census of its population had just been conducted there!
Drawing on unique Siberian migration data, Zaionchkovskaya was one of the first researchers to tackle the then wholly unexplored question of migrants’ adaptation, specifically in Siberia’s new towns.
Incidentally, on leaving MSU, Zhanna, like Viktor before her, received a departmental referral for postgraduate studies, but did not take it up. Why? Because at a “Postgraduates’ Ball” she took a strong dislike to Moscow postgraduate students as a type: collectively, they seemed worn out and exhausted.
In Novosibirsk, however, Zhanna took a laboratory-assistant post at Viktor’s institute and did not reject postgraduate study. In October 1963 she entered IEOIP’s four-year, full-time postgraduate programme. Her dissertation topic was “The Settlement and Retention of New Arrivals in Siberian Cities,” the intended degree was Candidate of Economic Sciences, and her supervisor was the already familiar Candidate of Economic Sciences Lev Vsevolodovich Starodubsky (1911-1987).
He was a man of remarkable experience, having worked before the war in Vienna (he held a doctorate from the University of Vienna!) and in Riga (as an adviser to the Latvian government). After moving to the USSR, and in particular to Novosibirsk, he became one of the architects of Siberia’s system of training highly qualified statisticians. He headed both the Department of National Economy and Socioeconomic Statistics at the Novosibirsk Institute of National Economy and IEOIP’s Labour Resources Division16.
Zaionchkovskaya was one of the ten postgraduate students he launched into serious scholarship. She was by no means a tormented postgraduate. She approached her duties conscientiously and was absorbed in her work: every day she went to the institute as though to an office job, though she was under no obligation to do so.
Meanwhile, a little baby cooed at home. Their daughter Sasha was born in Akademgorodok in 1964. Zhanna Antonovna herself initiated this family demographic boom: she very much wanted a child! Her husband said, “How will you manage? Your dissertation, your work, and now a baby!” She replied, “Don’t worry, Viktór, I’ll manage somehow!”
In practice, “somehow” meant that the baby had a nanny from the age of eight months, while her mother did not manage to finish the dissertation on time or at the place where she had undertaken her postgraduate studies.
6. Back to Moscow. New Settlers in the Capital
In 1967 the Perevedentsevs returned to Moscow. They registered their residence at his mother’s address and lived for a while in rented accommodation. At the end of 1969, however, they moved into their own three-room cooperative apartment on Sumskoy Proyezd. Both lived there until their deaths: Viktor Ivanovich died on 18 May 2009 and Zhanna Antonovna on 28 November 2021.
Having returned to Moscow and barely settled in, Viktor’s first priority was to make his wife finish and defend her dissertation. Their daughter was even sent for a time to stay with her grandmother in Poltava. It was a drastic measure, but needed only briefly. The dissertation was quickly completed, its topic remained “The Settlement and Retention of New Arrivals in Siberian Cities,” and the transition from postgraduate study in economics to a Candidate of Geographical Sciences degree caused no difficulties. On 12 June 1968, Zhanna Zaionchkovskaya defended her dissertation at her own MSU Geography Faculty; Starodubsky was her supervisor, and Kovalev and Sonin were the official opponents17.
Not immediately, but before long, the dissertation became the monograph New Settlers in Cities (1972), a groundbreaking analysis for its time of migrants’ ability to put down roots in Siberia, based on the 1959 census and field surveys. At the heart of the argument was the need for humane living conditions in receiving areas comparable to those people had left behind. An intelligent state interested in retaining people at particular growth centres must provide such conditions itself, from the very outset and indeed in advance. This had not happened in the Siberian regions she studied, or partly in the Far East. The book brought Zaionchkovskaya recognition and authority among both practitioners and academics.
As for Viktor Ivanovich, he initially hoped, on returning to Moscow, to rejoin MSU at the Population Studies Centre of the Faculty of Economics. That did not work out, and instead he joined, for the rest of his life, one of the principal centres of the 1960s generation’s free thinking in the USSR: the academic Institute of the International Labour Movement (IILM), established in 196618. Its director until 2003 was Timur Timofeyevich Timofeyev (1929-2013), a corresponding member of the USSR Academy of Sciences and a “child of the Comintern.”19
By then Perevedentsev himself was already moving away from a purely academic career towards public education and journalism. Beginning in the 1960s, his principal public platform was Literaturnaya Gazeta, with its readership of millions. His articles combined exceptional professional expertise with vivid, emotional writing and often sounded the first alarm about the country’s demographic, social, environmental and other problems. They were written so that readers invariably understood them and sometimes even the authorities did.
He travelled throughout the country and knew the Soviet and post-Soviet world exceptionally well. Some of his ostensibly alarmist articles were almost prophetic: he anticipated interethnic crises in Central Asia and the Caucasus and argued that the state should gently encourage Russian-speaking residents to move from those regions to Russia proper before a crisis erupted. One of his central themes was the residence-permit system, or propiska, against which, along with its disguised successor, “registration,” he struggled throughout his life, with mixed success.
Creative energy and talent, and independence of judgment, were combined in him with remarkable modesty and devotion to his family. He decidedly preferred solitude in nature to the social life of the city. From the forest, which he knew intimately, Viktór brought home not only well-developed thoughts but also nature’s generous gifts: mushrooms, nuts and berries. The thoughts went into articles, and the berries, especially the serviceberry known as the “wine berry,” into his signature homemade fruit liqueurs.
And despite her desk piled high with papers, the mistress of the house was no less capable at the kitchen and dining tables. There was always soup and a main course at home. She even baked little pies and made vareniki dumplings! Ah, those cherry-filled vareniki of hers!
Guests were loved and welcomed, with preference for intimate family gatherings over large social occasions. This allowed people to concentrate on what they shared without losing themselves in a crowd. Zhanna Antonovna’s lovely, almost elder-sisterly smile never left her face. At the dinner table even Viktor Ivanovich, otherwise reserved and taciturn, came alive and plunged into conversation. Whatever the subject, no one argued recklessly; they discussed and exchanged opinions.
Few places were as humanly comfortable and as warmly welcoming as Perevedentsev and Zaionchkovskaya’s home on Sumskoy Proyezd.
7. Moscow, USSR. Migration between Labour Resources and Settlement Patterns
On returning to Moscow, Zaionchkovskaya could have joined IILM, with its relaxed working arrangements, but did not want to work in the same institution as her husband again. Their ideas of good working conditions were diametrically opposed. He was a home-based scholar and a typical loner, disinclined towards collegial interaction: his ideal was to sit at the typewriter from morning till night and go to the office no more than twice a week on designated attendance days. She, with her energetic character, needed communication and the bustle of colleagues like the air she breathed. Thus a regular daily schedule initially suited her perfectly and did not trouble her, though it would later do so.
On 19 February 1968, even before defending her dissertation, Zhanna Antonovna began work at the Council for the Study of Productive Forces (SOPS) under the USSR State Planning Committee20. It was a very serious institution, with accordingly strict rules. At that time SOPS was responsible for preparing general plans for the development of the Soviet national economy by sector and region. This required territorial monitoring of the population, not as a civil society with its own interests and problems, but in narrowly functional terms as labour resources with no independent agency.
At SOPS she was appointed a junior researcher in the Territorial Proportions Division, later the Territorial Problems Division, initially on a temporary and then a permanent basis21. By 1969 she was a senior researcher; in October 1974 she became head of the Labour Resources Laboratory, later called the Regional Demography Laboratory. In 1976 she became head of the Division of Regional Population and Labour Resource Problems.
Although at SOPS Zhanna worked on labour balances and long-term labour-market forecasting, the central subject of her own research and publications, often marked “For Official Use,” remained migration and its links with regional economies. It seems she continued her contacts with Mikhail Sonin, the first Soviet demographer specializing in labour, who, like Perevedentsev, was an active and popular commentator in the leading Soviet newspapers.
The strict attendance rules at SOPS did not in themselves trouble her, and access to real statistical data excited her. Gradually, however, the dreadful overload of routine planned tasks and urgent exceptional assignments, compounded by the work regime, became almost unbearable. She was also troubled by her inability to devote time to Sasha, her only and beloved daughter, towards whom she already felt guilty.
Thus, when Georgy Mikhailovich Lappo (1923-2020), head of the Department of Economic Geography at the Institute of Geography of the USSR Academy of Sciences (IGAN), invited Zaionchkovskaya to join his institute in 1980, she gladly accepted, even though it meant losing a quarter of her salary. Altogether she worked at SOPS for thirteen and a half years, from February 1968 to September 1980.
Compared with SOPS, IGAN offered complete freedom in terms of state assignments and working hours! There was only one designated attendance day a week, rather than the two at IILM22. Yet because she now felt a shortage of communication, Zaionchkovskaya turned even this comfortable academic position into a demanding job for herself, travelling almost every day from Chertanovo to 29 Staromonetny Lane in Zamoskvorechye. When writing her book about settlement systems, she would also spend long periods in the institute library. In other words, she tried to marry the external “IGAN” with the internal “SOPS” that remained within her.
From 1980 to 1989 she was a senior researcher in the Population Geography Department, and from August 1986 a leading researcher in the Population Geography Laboratory. Within this population-research unit she led work on the interrelations between population migration and the evolution of settlement systems. The author of these lines was, to his pleasure and benefit, among her closest colleagues.
Our summer field seasons together, whether in Georgia, Dagestan or Novgorod region, were both a celebration and real scholarship. Zhanna Antonovna took part in my expedition team on four occasions, in 1983 and from 1986 to 1988. Her thirst for new, unexplored places and new human encounters never left her. Her experience and sensitivity were invaluable both in interpreting the data and in overcoming the challenges of collecting it.
In Dagestan in 1983 we encountered a sharp mismatch between mountain settlement and mountain economic activity. While the population was undergoing a revolutionary change through voluntary migration to the lowlands, economic activities were in effect shifting there too, to so-called kutans. Yet the administrative system clung to the past, stubbornly ignoring lowland realities and attributing all productive and demographic “assets” to the mountain villages. We therefore regarded mountain farming in its existing form as an anachronism: was it possible or desirable to keep propping it up and reviving it? The mountain population was growing only slowly despite a high, though declining, natural increase23.
For an inveterate empiricist and inductive thinker like Zaionchkovskaya in Novosibirsk and at SOPS, the chance to try her hand at theory was irresistible. All the more so because it was still the same Lady Empiricism that encouraged theorizing, or rather reflection! Several economic geographers studying rural settlement in the 1980s, including G. V. Ioffe and L. V. Fuks, observed from different examples that a settlement’s location relative to a central city had already become its principal typological characteristic, most objectively reflecting real processes of rural settlement. In other words, town and countryside entered into relationships in which rural population density rose as one approached the city, while the attractiveness of agricultural employment declined.
This approach fitted well with Zhanna Antonovna’s general concept of the stage-by-stage evolution of settlement. To the conventional static picture of settlement she added population dynamics, across three intercensal periods (1926-1939, 1940-1959 and 1960-1979), distinguishing between rural and urban areas. This led her to devise an original theory of settlement stages and to understand migration flows as the main channels through which changes in settlement patterns accumulate and evolve.
She distinguished three stages: autonomous, concentrated and integrated settlement. In the first two, urban and rural settlement coexist, separately in the first and in an interrelated but still distinct way in the second, as though one formed the background to the other. At the third stage, the two become intertwined and integrated on a common foundation, enabling shorter, more intensive production links and giving the population access to a full range of activities and services. Settlement changes gradually from continuous and relatively even to patchy, while town and countryside become “communicating vessels” that can be managed only by regulating the system as a whole. She noted that integrated settlement had long existed in urban agglomerations, which were thus forerunners and outposts of this stage while earlier forms of settlement still predominated elsewhere.
The principal outcome of Zaionchkovskaya’s IGAN period was her monograph The Demographic Situation and Settlement (1991)24. It presented both her theory of settlement stages and her masterly descriptions of migration processes, changes in population dynamics and differentiation in the sectoral structure of the economy. She also identified an increasingly powerful migration megatrend: movement from rural areas to the largest cities, and from the east and north of the USSR to the southwest of its European part. Her book was among the first to discuss openly repression, particularly forced migration and deportation, as factors shaping settlement patterns.
It was also at IGAN that Zaionchkovskaya first supervised doctoral research. In 1987, for example, Vladimir Shkolnikov defended a dissertation under her guidance on regional differences in mortality25.
Zaionchkovskaya’s monograph appeared in 1991, by which time she had already left IGAN. That was the pivotal year in which the USSR disintegrated and a new post-Soviet space was born, requiring Russia too to reinvent itself and seek its place in the world and among foreign countries. With excessive self-confidence, the latter were divided into the “far abroad” and the “near abroad,” the near abroad encompassing the entire former Union except Russia, though the Baltic states were eventually excluded, and not immediately.
8. Moscow, Russian Federation. Migration: A Kaleidoscope of Projects, Councils and Centres
The next phase of Zhanna Antonovna’s life and academic career would have been unimaginable without these changes. She herself summed up this phase in a single word: “projects.”
If her thirteen years at SOPS can be called an applied-scientific phase, with the emphasis on application and little opportunity for broader scholarship because both data and results were partly restricted, and her ten years at IGAN an academic phase crowned by a major theoretical monograph, the following thirty years constituted a phase of scientific organization and leadership.
Her main subject, migration, to which she had devoted her entire scholarly life, suddenly became both open to research and highly sought-after. She herself came to be seen by foreign colleagues and Russian officials alike as a guru and a classic figure of migration studies. Proposals and commissions for projects from Russia and abroad poured in without end. While retaining her core identity as a researcher, she revealed and developed an exceptional natural talent for organization and leadership: the desire and ability to activate a lifetime’s contacts, build a collaborative intellectual environment around herself, and assemble and unite a research team, even an international one.
All this, of course, had a particular institutional context and strategy. Zaionchkovskaya had not left IGAN without a reason: she accepted the persistent invitation of her close friend and colleague Anatoly Grigoryevich Vishnevsky (1935-2021), founding director of an innovative academic institute established in 1988, the Institute of Socioeconomic Problems of Population of the USSR Academy of Sciences and the USSR State Labour Committee (ISEPP)26. Vishnevsky and his colleagues hoped to revive the traditions of the Academy’s Demographic Institute, which had been closed in 1934.
Initially, ISEPP’s staff consisted mainly of young demographers and sociologists who had transferred from the Demography Department of the Academy’s Institute of Sociology. Zhanna Antonovna accepted Vishnevsky’s proposal and transferred from IGAN to ISEPP on 20 February 1989 as a leading researcher. In July of that year she became head of the Economic Demography Laboratory, renamed the Population Geography Laboratory in January 1991.
Vishnevsky’s strategy was to strengthen the emerging team of demographers, which already included many promising young researchers but generally few with academic degrees, making them ineligible for administrative posts. As soon as Vladimir Shkolnikov, who had defended a dissertation under Zaionchkovskaya in 1987, arrived at the institute, a Mortality Studies Laboratory was established for him. When Sergei Zakharov defended his dissertation in early 1991, a Family and Fertility Studies Laboratory followed. ISEPP had already become a prototype for a Centre for Demography, a concept Vishnevsky refined at each subsequent institutional stage. Within this framework, Zhanna Antonovna could at last concentrate specifically on migration research and on directing that research.
In May 1991, during the painful transition from Soviet to Russian institutions, most of the Demography Department’s staff, including Zaionchkovskaya’s entire laboratory, accepted Vishnevsky’s invitation to move to another newly created institution, the Institute of Employment Problems (IEP), again jointly subordinated to the Ministry of Labour and the Academy of Sciences. Its director was Alexander Nikolayevich Shokhin, who only three months later, in August 1991, immediately after the attempted coup, rose rapidly to ministerial and deputy prime ministerial positions in the government27. Vishnevsky remained deputy director and head of the Centre for Demography. Most employees moved with him, including Zaionchkovskaya’s entire laboratory. The next two years of her professional life, from April 1991 to September 1993, were spent here amid the country’s extraordinarily difficult political and economic circumstances28.
One of the laboratory heads at Shokhin’s institute was Tatyana Regent, my former classmate at the Geography Faculty, who had defended her Candidate of Sciences dissertation there in 1981 on “Social Aspects of the Geographical Study of Rural Population.” She too rose rapidly after Shokhin: in January 1992 she became first deputy chair of the Committee on Population Migration under his Ministry of Labour and Employment, and in July she became the first head of Russia’s Federal Migration Service.
A persistent rumour has it that Shokhin first offered that post to Zaionchkovskaya, but that she, avoiding an official career, declined and suggested Regent instead. Having accepted, Regent stayed in the position almost longer than any other “technocrat” or “laboratory head” brought into government in the Gaidar era, until 15 February 1999.
Zhanna Antonovna’s longest-serving employer was the Institute of Economic Forecasting of the Russian Academy of Sciences (IEF), housed on several floors of the famous “House with the Ear” at 47 Nakhimovsky Prospekt. After the Institute of Employment Problems collapsed, Vishnevsky’s entire Centre for Demography moved there. She worked there for a long twenty-six years, heading the Migration Analysis and Forecasting Laboratory from 1993 to 2018, including the years 1993-2006 within the Centre for Demography and Human Ecology (CDHE). Soon after a group of medical geographers and environmental scientists led by B. B. Prokhorov joined the institute, the Centre for Demography expanded its name to the Centre for Demography and Human Ecology of the IEF. During Vishnevsky and his colleagues’ time at the institute, traditions of regular demographic publications emerged and developed: the bulletin Population and Society, the electronic fortnightly Demoscope Weekly, and the annual demographic report Population of Russia.
On 15 August 1997 the Centre for the Study of Forced Migration in the CIS was established; in March 2004 it became the Centre for Migration Studies (CMS). Zhanna Antonovna served as its director until 23 January 2008 and thereafter as scientific director (deputy director)29.
This change of status was connected partly with the fact that the main group of demographers around Vishnevsky moved institutional homes once again, and for the last time. February 2007 saw the foundation of the Institute of Demography (IDEM) at the National Research University Higher School of Economics (HSE), now named after its founder following his death from COVID-19. Most moved permanently to HSE’s side of the river, so to speak, but some, Zhanna Antonovna among them, kept one foot on the original bank.
On 9 January 2008 she joined IDEM as a leading researcher at the Centre for Demographic Research and became one of its essential pillars. Her duties included the sections on migration in the Population of Russia annual reports. On 1 March 2018 she transferred to the Centre for Qualitative Social Policy Research at HSE’s Institute for Social Policy as a leading expert, working there for two years until resigning on 16 March 2020. On 15 January of that year she received the university medal “Recognition: Ten Years of Successful Work.”
On the “old” bank, from early April 2018 she also worked as a leading researcher in the Laboratory for Forecasting Environmental Quality and Population Health. Almost exactly a year later, on 28 March 2019, she finally left the Centre and said farewell to the familiar “House with the Ear” near Profsoyuznaya, which she knew down to its veins and could scarcely leave without tears30.
But all this is merely the external outline of her career, a chronology of entries in her employment record. Throughout those years Zaionchkovskaya was immersed, from top to bottom, in an extraordinary variety of projects, generally innovative and pioneering ones.
In the early 1990s Zhanna Antonovna began an especially fruitful collaboration with historical-educational and human rights organizations. One example was our joint questionnaire survey of former Ostarbeiters, civilians of Slavic origin from German-occupied territories who had been ruthlessly deported to Germany for forced labour. We carried out a representative pilot survey of these Ostarbeiters, investigating their backgrounds, fates and other circumstances. We summarized the results in an article published in German and Russian31.
The current migration agenda throughout the post-Soviet area offered an equally broad field for collaboration with human rights advocates. The dissolution of the Soviet Union was not as bloody as the break-up of Yugoslavia, but neither was it as peaceful as the separation of Czechoslovakia. Even under Gorbachev it triggered armed conflicts in different parts of the former USSR, and those conflicts generated flows of refugees and displaced people. Under Yeltsin such migrants became a mass phenomenon, marked also by acute legal vulnerability. They needed not only material aid but information and legal assistance, which Russian human rights organizations provided effectively in close collaboration with the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. Zhanna Antonovna worked with rights advocates to study and understand this phenomenon.
The economic dimension of migration, especially international migration, was no less important. Zaionchkovskaya regarded migration as a natural process and a vital instrument for addressing the problems of both countries of origin and countries receiving migrants. She consistently and firmly supported a strategy for attracting large numbers of labour migrants to Russia legally and pragmatically, without a trace of xenophobia or discrimination, from other post-Soviet states, especially Ukraine and Central Asia, and from China beyond the former Soviet area. Russia’s irreversible depopulation and the demographic trough into which it had fallen left it no alternative except much worse ones.
Her opponents, especially in nationalist circles, accused her of pro-Western sympathies, lobbying to bring in migrants and replace the native population, undermining the foundations of national identity, and downplaying the “yellow peril” in Siberia and the Far East. They did not shrink from online insults or threats to her personal safety, especially when interethnic tensions intensified in Russia, as during the unrest in Kondopoga in 2006 and Biryulyovo in 2013.
While working at the IEF, Zaionchkovskaya forged extensive contacts with foreign colleagues, particularly Americans. She actively helped initiate and conduct independent studies of post-Soviet migration, created a network of migration researchers across most CIS countries, and organized international conferences, seminars and round tables. At her initiative, the Independent Research Council on Migration in the CIS and Baltic States (IRCM) was founded in 1996. It monitored migration throughout the former Soviet area in cooperation with the International Organization for Migration (IOM) and other international and civil society organizations from post-Soviet countries.
As participants in these institutions unanimously recall, this made it possible to preserve and sustain the ties between demographers and migration specialists in post-Soviet countries, including the Baltic states, that had developed during the Soviet period. Scholars in these countries were immensely grateful that she brought them together, introduced them to one another, united them in a kind of confederation, and prevented them from thoughtlessly turning away from each other in their research and methods. Zaionchkovskaya also helped establish UNESCO’s Central and East European Network on Migration Research (CEENOM).
International migration, a subject almost unstudied during the Soviet era, became urgent after the USSR’s dissolution in the 1990s and for a time even took centre stage in Zaionchkovskaya’s work. For example, her studies with G. S. Vitkovskaya of Chinese immigration to Russia in 1997-1998 attracted widespread attention. At the same time, internal migration remained a focus: researchers examined mobility within Russia and developed forecasts for the country as a whole and for individual federal districts.
Much of her work was pioneering and, given the urgency of migration problems across the world, greatly in demand. During this period the Migration Analysis and Forecasting Laboratory and IRCM under her direction conducted a series of studies and published a series of books edited by Zaionchkovskaya. Studying how market and political reforms transformed migration in Russia and other post-Soviet countries, she examined forced migration, the brain drain from those countries, labour immigration to Russia from China and elsewhere, and historical migration processes, notably Stalinist deportations and the previously mentioned deportation of Soviet civilians to Germany for labour during the Great Patriotic War.
Zaionchkovskaya worked just as closely with Russian state bodies. She served on the governing boards of the Federal Migration Service (1993-1997) and the Ministry for Federation, National and Migration Affairs (1999-2000); on the Russian Government Commission on Migration Policy (2002-2004); on the Moscow Government’s Interdepartmental Commission for Analysing the City’s Demographic Situation (2005-2007); and on the public and scientific councils of Russia’s Federal Migration Service (from 2007). She was also a member of the Russian Academy of Sciences’ Social Sciences Division scientific council on national policy (from 2005), and expert councils of the Federation Council’s CIS Affairs Committee and the Government Commission on Compatriots Abroad (from 2006). She received numerous medals and awards for her contribution to the nationwide Russian censuses of 2002 and 2010, among other achievements.
Zhanna Antonovna served on the editorial boards of the Demographic Yearbook of Russia (2002-2006) and several journals: Migration: The Twenty-First Century, Russian Migration and Migracijske i etničke teme (Zagreb, Croatia). In the annual Population of Russia (1993-2017, issues 1-25), she oversaw the migration section, contributing reviews of her own. At her initiative, Russia’s first annotated bibliography, Population Migration in Post-Soviet States (covering 1992-1997), appeared in 1998; a bibliographic index for 1992-1999 followed in 2000; and in 2013 she edited the Annotated Bibliographic Index of Academic Literature on Migration Published in Russia, 2000-2011.
Her personal scholarly output amounts to 335 publications, excluding newspaper articles and interviews. These include ten authored or co-authored books and eleven collected volumes she compiled or edited.
But such dry figures are little better than the entries in an employment record. They do not by themselves establish Zaionchkovskaya as a classic figure in migration scholarship. Reading the works themselves does!
As Yulia Florinskaya observes, almost all of Zhanna Antonovna’s projects were innovative, linked by a single word: “first.” She was the first to study cross-border or frontier migration (Russia-China, Russia-Kazakhstan, Russia-Ukraine and so on), labour and commercial migration in Russia and the other former Soviet republics as a way of adapting to economic crisis, including portraits of the famous “shuttle traders” with their enormous checked bags! The same pioneering character marked her research on migration mobility in Russian cities, the effects of migration-law changes on migrants’ status and legalization, and migration under conditions of demographic crisis.
In 2019, gradually retiring and withdrawing from many familiar activities, Zhanna Antonovna began devoting her available time to Perevedentsev’s archive, sorting it and transferring it in instalments to the Russian State Archive of the Economy. She gave her own professional archive and library to Dmitry Poletayev, the present head of the Centre for Migration Studies that she had founded.
She died at home on 28 November 2021, in the arms of her loving daughter...
9. The Queen of “Gentle” Acts, or a Declaration of Love
Throughout her life, not only in adulthood but also in youth and even childhood, Zhanna Antonovna Zaionchkovskaya made independent, resolute and fearless choices. At first sight they seemed gentle and rounded, but in reality they were immensely difficult transitions, literal leaps from one state of being to another, always towards something new that beckoned forward and upward.
Consider the outstanding schoolgirl from the provinces who decided to apply not to the local university in Poltava, or even the regional one in Kharkiv, but to the country’s supreme temple of learning, Moscow State University!
Consider the eighteen-year-old second-year student who, with absolute conviction, married a twenty-eight-year-old “old man,” a fifth-year student with the telling name Viktór!
At his first invitation she travelled with him and after him to the very Siberia that had for centuries been invoked to frighten both law-abiding and less obedient Russian citizens.
There, while undertaking postgraduate studies and living in a hostel, she decided to have a child and gave birth to a daughter! Her “I’ll manage somehow” was no fatalistic reliance on chance or empty reassurance, but an instinctive confidence in her own abilities. And she did manage, did she not?
And here is the Polish-Ukrainian girl, the “pani” as Viktor Ivanovich called her, who retained her native Ukrainian language and, in her charming Polish accent, traces of her ancestral Polish speech, mastering Russian so completely that the compelling logic of her writing and speeches made it impossible to look away.
Her hallmark was an immersion in the country’s history, understood as complete only when seen through the history of families and individual human beings. Hence her love of fieldwork, questionnaires and memoir material. Despite her enormous workload, it took little persuasion for her to recall the war as seen through the eyes of a little girl in German-occupied territory, in her grandmother’s village of Rybtsy near Poltava.
And here she is, listening kindly to flattering offers, but turning down with equal firmness and a smile both invitations to join the Communist Party and appeals to defend a higher doctoral dissertation. Even after becoming the country’s leading migration specialist, she declined to bring her formal qualifications into line with her actual standing, sincerely believing she would “manage somehow” and that the bureaucratic reward was not worth the time and effort32. Recall too her refusal to head the Federal Migration Service, a ministerial-level post.
This very combination, gentle on the outside and firm within, was another of her defining characteristics.
Whether she worked with economists at SOPS, geographers at IGAN, or demographers at the IEF and later institutions, she always remained an essentially synthetic and synthesizing figure. In Elena Maslenkova’s words, she was a leader of a rare and subtle kind, at once soloist and conductor, the first violin of the unique orchestra that invariably gathered around her. A kind of Vladimir Spivakov of geodemography!
Blending her scientific and non-scientific lives into a single current was another hallmark of Zhanna Antonovna. Her vocation was to create and sustain around herself an indivisible environment at once intellectual and human, in which one felt what Irina Badyshtova so aptly called “an embrace of the soul,” an uplifting influence. Nadezhda Nozdrina said something similar: “Her scientific works were marked by the same humanity: for her there was no such thing as dry science. This was so rare, and it was what drew people to her.” Maria Savoskul echoes them in the words I chose as an epigraph.
Yulia Florinskaya emphasizes a slightly different aspect: “For us, as young researchers, every project was another step up the ladder into the profession. And at the top of that ladder stood Zhanna Antonovna Zaionchkovskaya, reaching out her hand to help us climb. [...] Zhanna Antonovna was one of the most radiant people I have encountered. At the same time, I clearly remember how she defended her views kindly but very firmly and persistently, regardless of the other person’s titles or rank. That was something we wanted to learn as well...”
For Arif Yunusov, she was not only an unquestioned authority on migration but also “a symbol of the Russian intelligentsia.”
What always amazed us about Zhanna Antonovna was her scientific intuition, her ability to discern coherent patterns behind a forest of figures. In his obituary, Alexander Alekseev pointed to one of her profound but underrated discoveries in migration studies: interregional migration cycles related both to demographic waves and to the availability of labour and jobs in different regions of the USSR33.
How easily she could pick truly significant facts out of a stream of information and synthesize them into fascinating conclusions. Everything could serve as evidence, including herself. How often, when making the most sophisticated generalizations, she found excellent arguments and exact illustrations in her own life or the lives of those close to her.
Her exceptionally rare analytical gift was joined to an instinctive yet principled warmth and humanity in her dealings not only with relatives and colleagues but also with the people she studied in large numbers. Behind the multitude, behind the forest, she always saw the individual and the personality. This was particularly evident in conversation and oral discussion: written forms resist, even fight against, such personalization.
And yet one felt comfortable with Zhanna Antonovna everywhere: on a field expedition without everyday comforts, in a European capital at a world congress, or in a Moscow café. Best of all was her home on Simferopolskaya Street, with Viktor’s serviceberry liqueur and spring water, and Zhanna’s Poltava-style vareniki filled with cherries from the Moscow region!
Zhanna Antonovna Zaionchkovskaya possessed the art of friendship and knew how to create an attracting, almost magnetic atmosphere around herself. Thus, whatever angle one approaches her from, the result is always the same: not a Kalashnikov assault rifle, but a living memory and a declaration of love!
Footnotes
Remarkably, she did not even tell her daughter about this discovery. Even more remarkably, “Anton Nartsissovich Zaionchkovsky” is still absent from the excellent Podvig Naroda (“Feat of the People”) database. ↩
E. Bogdanova, V. Vycherov, Zh. Zaionchkovskaya and B. Mironov, Childhood under Occupation: Recollections of Those Who Could Not Yet Write during the War, compiled by N. Pobol and P. Polyan, foreword by P. Polyan (Moscow: Russian Political Encyclopedia [ROSSPEN], 2010), “A Person on the Margins of War” series. ↩
Today it is certainly part of the city, since new houses and neighbourhoods are now being built beyond Rybtsy. ↩
For some, of course, it was tragic. ↩
In an interview about her teachers, Zh. Z. especially praised the breadth of the Geography Faculty teachers’ outlook. She compared the faculty, with its varied departments, to a department store (recorded by D. Poletayev in 2017). Available online: https://disk.yandex.ru/i/tmMO5OqSNvJxRA ↩
Now the Department of Economic and Social Geography of Russia. ↩
Pokshishevsky defended his Candidate of Sciences dissertation on 26 June 1941: “Territorial Conditions in the Formation of the Industrial Complex of Petersburg-Leningrad.” It was published only in 2025, as was his doctoral dissertation, “The Geography of Population Migration in Russia: A Historical-Geographical Study” (the publication of both owes an enormous debt to A. A. Agirrechu, M. S. Savoskul and the Kuchkovo Pole publishing house). He did, however, manage to publish his un-defended doctoral research: V. V. Pokshishevsky, The Settlement of Siberia: Historical-Geographical Essays, ed. V. A. Krotov (Irkutsk: Irkutsk Regional State Publishing House, 1951), 207 pp. It is interesting in its own way that Pokshishevsky’s and Perevedentsev’s contributions to migration studies intersected precisely on the subject of Western Siberia! ↩
For this reason, the paper itself was placed in the restricted-access collection. ↩
In 1964, almost the entire graduation thesis was published in Novosibirsk, practically unchanged, as a booklet co-authored with V. I. Perevedentsev: Zh. A. Zaionchkovskaya and V. I. Perevedentsev, Contemporary Population Migration in Krasnoyarsk Territory (Novosibirsk: Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Institute of Economics and Organization of Industrial Production, 1964), 105 pp. ↩
N. Ya. Kovalskaya, Methods of Economic-Geographical Research (Moscow: Moscow State University, 1963), according to A. I. Alekseev. ↩
For example, see G. M. Lappo, N. V. Mkrtchyan and P. M. Polyan, “Viktor Ivanovich Perevedentsev (3 January 1931-18 May 2009)” (obituary), Izvestiya AN, no. 4 (2009): 135-136; and P. M. Polyan, “Peace to the New Arrival, or a Man in an Administrative Draught” (foreword), in V. Perevedentsev, Migration in the Rhythm of Time (Moscow: New Eurasia Foundation, 2010), 4-8. ↩
In fact, when the time came he was not accepted into the army at all because of poor eyesight. ↩
The dissertation abstract bore a slightly different title: “Contemporary Population Migration in Western Siberia” (https://rusneb.ru/catalog/000199_000009_006466674/). His supervisor was most probably Evgeny Tikhonovich Kasimovsky, Doctor of Economic Sciences and one of Siberia’s leading specialists in labour resources and migration. ↩
V. I. Perevedentsev, Contemporary Population Migration in Western Siberia (Novosibirsk: West Siberian Book Publishers, 1965), 95 pp.; V. I. Perevedentsev, Population Migration and Labour Problems in Siberia (Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1966), 192 pp.; Zh. A. Zaionchkovskaya and V. I. Perevedentsev, Contemporary Population Migration in Krasnoyarsk Territory (Novosibirsk: Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences, IEOIP, 1964), 105 pp. ↩
V. I. Perevedentsev, Methods of Studying Population Migration (Moscow: Nauka, 1975), 232 pp. ↩
For more on him, see L. P. Kharchenko, “Lev Vsevolodovich Starodubsky (1911-1987),” Bulletin of the Novosibirsk State University of Economics and Management, no. 2 (2011): 277-285. Among his principal works were: L. V. Starodubsky, The Decline of Factory Industry in Bourgeois Latvia (Riga: Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the Latvian SSR, 1952), 222 pp.; L. V. Starodubsky, “On the Role of Statistics in the Process of Cognition,” Proceedings of the Academy of Sciences of the Latvian SSR, no. 10 (1956): 153-170; and L. V. Starodubsky, Methods for Preparing and Analysing Planned Labour-Resource Balances of Towns and Rural Districts (Novosibirsk: Institute of Economics, Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences, 1966), 64 pp. ↩
Sonin, incidentally, was also an official opponent at the dissertation defences of A. G. Aganbegyan and A. G. Vishnevsky, among others. ↩
Later renamed the Institute of Comparative Political Science and subsequently incorporated into, and absorbed by, the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences. ↩
He came from the family of one of the general secretaries of the Communist Party of the USA. ↩
The director was Academician Nikolai Nikolayevich Nekrasov (1906-1984), a distinguished economist with a regional-studies orientation. ↩
This and subsequent information on Zhanna Antonovna Zaionchkovskaya’s formal career is taken from her employment record book, to which D. V. Poletayev gave me access. ↩
On the Institute of Geography at that time and its particular characteristics, see P. M. Polyan, Geographical Arabesques: Spaces of Inspiration, Freedom and Unfreedom (Moscow: Ikar, 2017), 57-59. ↩
Zaionchkovskaya’s theses during the discussion, at the IGAN Population Geography Department meeting of 18 October 1983, of P. Polyan’s report on the 1983 expedition (P. Polyan, Geographical Arabesques: Spaces of Inspiration, Freedom and Unfreedom [Moscow: Ikar, 2017], 639). ↩
Zh. A. Zaionchkovskaya, The Demographic Situation and Settlement (Moscow: Nauka, 1991), 130 pp. ↩
See his recollections in the present volume. ↩
Now the N. M. Rimashevskaya Institute of Socioeconomic Problems of Population, a separate division of the Federal Centre of Theoretical and Applied Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences. It is named after Natalya Mikhailovna Rimashevskaya (1932-2017), a corresponding member of the Russian Academy of Sciences who later headed the institute. ↩
He served as Minister of Labour, Minister of Labour and Employment, and Minister of Economy of the RSFSR/Russian Federation, alongside deputy-chairmanships of the RSFSR/Russian Federation Government for social policy. He remained in government until the end of 1994. ↩
Suffice it to say that despite the high position of its nominal director A. N. Shokhin, the IEP failed to pay its rent on time and lost its premises on Malaya Lubyanka by court order to the then-famous newspaper Megapolis-Express. Employees had to take the computers home and meet at Vishnevsky’s apartment. ↩
From that date the CMS director was Elena Vladimirovna Tyuryukanova (1959-2012); after her death, in September 2012, Dmitry Vyacheslavovich Poletayev succeeded her. ↩
The building of the Central Economics and Mathematics Institute at 47 Nakhimovsky Prospekt, near Profsoyuznaya metro station, which also housed the IEF. ↩
See P. M. Polyan and Zh. A. Zaionchkovskaya, “Ostarbeiters: In Germany and at Home (Based on Questionnaire Survey Data),” in In Memoriam: Historical Collection in Memory of F. F. Perchenok (St Petersburg, 1995), 396-413; and P. Poljan and Zh. Zajončkovskaja, “Ostarbeiter in Deutschland und daheim: Ergebnisse einer Fragebogenanalyse,” Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas, Neue Folge 41, no. 4 (1993): 547-561. ↩
In this way she involuntarily joined a particular tradition among geographers of holding a degree lower than one’s actual scholarly standing, or even having no formal degree at all. Prominent among those without degrees were Leonid Isaakovich Vasilevsky and Yuri Konstantinovich Yefremov. ↩
Analysing interregional migration, she observed that when growth in the working-age population increased, the availability of jobs became a more important migration factor and migration grew towards areas with plentiful jobs, the regions of new development. When that growth declined, the opposite occurred. ↩