Editorial Dashboard

Account

My DashboardEditorial Dashboard

Editorial Dashboard

Assessment Sheet

To start the assessment, first give a general rating to the paper. Rate the entire paper from 1 to 10. Your rating will depend on quality of paper, impact it may have, language and other parameters all at once.

SECTION A

How would you rate paper overall ?

0 / 10

SECTION B

The Theme

As per your Section A rating and numerous other parameters we have used Artificial Intelligence to determine ratings for Section B. You may change them as per your analysis.

SECTION B.1

Integrity & Analysis of the Theme

How impactful is this Theme

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION B.1.1

Theme Analysis and Exploration

How author has analyzed and, explored the theme of the research?

SECTION B.1.2

Concept originality/Breakthrough

This does NOT refer to Plagiarism. This means how much enhanced in field author has made with respect to the previous referenced research

SECTION B.1.3

Presented Concept

This measures how much sufficiently novel is the article and has added new knowledge to the stream

SECTION B.1.4

How fundamental the concept is?

How close the concept is to the fundamental foundation or basis of the corresponding research in the stream? Given more mark if it is more fundamental.

SECTION B.1.5

Depth of the Research

The depth of theme and research work

SECTION B.1.6

The scope of stream

How is the article related to the scope of the stream?

SECTION B.1.7

Meaningful interpretation of the results

How logically has the author interpreted the results of the study

SECTION B.1.8

Logical Conclusions

Were any logical conclusions made by the author?

SECTION B.1.9

Relevance of the Article

How relevant is the research topic is with respect to the current needs in the stream ?

SECTION B.2

Extensibility of Research

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION B.2.1

Flexibility of Theory

The consistency of the conclusion with respect to the theory

SECTION B.2.2

Future aspects of Research

Whether the research topic is a hot topic of its stream

SECTION B.2.3

Flexibility of input data

If the results are consistent even if the input data is changed

SECTION B.3

Applications of Research

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION B.3.1

Direct impact of the research to industries

How much the research impacts directly to the industries for their betterment

SECTION B.3.2

Applications to interdisciplinary streams

How much is the research useful for multiple streams

SECTION B.3.3

Compatibility with local laws

It should not break any local laws, take US laws if unknown

SECTION C

Structural and Compilation Gradation of Article

Formatting is publisher's job, evaluation of the following is not based on the layout of the article.

SECTION C.1

Interactivity

SHOW DETAILS

Not Applicable

SECTION C.1.1

Proper headings

How author has analyzed and explored theme of the research?

SECTION C.1.2

Figures and Photographs

Relevance of theme and no figure should lack captions

SECTION C.1.3

Charts and Tables

Properly and nicely formatted

SECTION C.1.4

High resolution of images

More than 600 DPI (Dot Per Inch). Means graphics must not be blurry

SECTION C.1.5

Aspect Ratio

The ratio of the width to the height of an image must be correct

SECTION C.1.6

Vector images in case of illustrative figures

If figures are not photographs, they must be in vector format

SECTION C.2

Title, Abstract and Keywords

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.2.1

Title

The title of the paper effectively frames the study

SECTION C.2.2

Contains specific data

It should be relevant and summary of whole article

SECTION C.2.3

Single paragraph

It should be only of single paragraph

SECTION C.2.4

250 words or less

250 words or less are considered better

SECTION C.2.5

Grammar and spelling

Scientific terminologies used are correct and consistent

SECTION C.2.6

Clear and concise

It should have good readability

SECTION C.2.7

Translated to English

Title, abstract and keywords should be in English also even if the article is non-English.

SECTION C.2.8

Keywords

Keywords should be used correctly and consistently

SECTION C.3

Introduction Section

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.3.1

Background

Background and history of the topic should be well summarized

SECTION C.3.2

Appropriate depth

It should go into the proper details

SECTION C.3.3

Goal clearly stated

What a reader should expect from the article should also be stated

SECTION C.3.4

References cited

Reference in standard format like APA

SECTION C.3.5

Transition and flow

Content in introduction should be connecting, logical, clear, easy to follow

SECTION C.3.6

Grammar and spelling

Semantic report is sent separately, still you can judge

SECTION C.3.7

Sentence/paragraph structure

Subheadings in Introduction Section

SECTION C.4

Material & Methods Section

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.4.1

Complete and Detailed

Method specified should be reproducible

SECTION C.4.2

Reference cited

References are given in a standard style. For example, APA

SECTION C.4.3

Correct format

Method should be well structured

SECTION C.4.4

Grammar and Spelling

Thorough semantic report is sent separately, still this parameter is judged

SECTION C.4.5

Sentence/paragraph structure

Separate subsections for material and procedure

SECTION C.5

Article Content

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.5.1

Appropriate length

Length of the article should neither be to long nor too short depending on the type of article (review/original)

SECTION C.5.2

Reference cited

References are given in a standard style in the whole article. For example, APA

SECTION C.5.3

Transition and flow

Article's contents should be connecting, logical, clear, easy to follow

SECTION C.5.4

Grammar and Spelling

Thorough semantic report is sent separately, still this parameter is judged for the whole article

SECTION C.5.5

Sentence/paragraph structure

Proper structure of the whole article

SECTION C.6

Results Section

If results section is not required, mark NR

SHOW DETAILS

Not Applicable

SECTION C.6.1

Well organized results

Presentation of results section

SECTION C.6.2

Clear and concise

It should have good readability

SECTION C.6.3

Accuracy of results in prima facie

If result data looks correct

SECTION C.6.4

Standalone readability

Can anyone read results section without reading whole article ?

SECTION C.6.5

Grammar and Spelling

Semantic report is sent separately, still you can judge

SECTION C.6.6

Sentence/paragraph structure

Separate subsections for material and procedure

SECTION C.7

Discussion/Conclusion Section

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.7.1

Overall discussion

Conclusion, merits and demerits of the research should be clearly stated

SECTION C.7.2

Integration with theory

How is the conclusion related to the theory presented in the article

SECTION C.7.3

References cited in the comments section

Reference in standard format like APA

SECTION C.7.4

Concise and appropriate

Authors arrived at clear, well-supported and evidence-based conclusions

SECTION C.7.5

Logical conclusions

Conclusion deduced should be logically correct and obvious

SECTION C.7.6

Grammar and spelling

Thorough semantic report is sent separately, still this parameter is judged for the conclusion section

SECTION C.7.7

Dissenting arguments scope

Better if variance of expressed opinions with the tradition is high

SECTION C.7.8

Acknowledgements

Acknowledgement and conflict of interest should be stated

SECTION C.7.9

References/Bibliography

Literature Cited section should have complete citation information in standard format

SECTION C.8

To be Filled by Editor

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.8.1

Number of Authors

Less score when more than 5 authors

SECTION C.8.2

Author's credibility

To be judged by Editors

SECTION C.8.3

Corresponding author's country's contribution to research

Directly calculated by System

SECTION D

Comment and Recommendation

SECTION D.1

Comment

SECTION D.2

Your Recommendation

Publish As It Is (The article fulfills all of the requirements listed above and is ready for publication).

Minor Revision. (The article contains a small number of easily correctable errors including grammar, missing references, and minor content clarification).

Major Revision. (The article has significant deficiencies in content and grammar).

Not Suitable for Publication. (The article is not suitable for publication).

Reject & Resubmit. (The article in its current form is not suitable for publication and requires significant rewrites for more than 50% of the manuscript. However, it does contain value and after taking into consideration the reviewer’s comments would be worthy of an evaluation for future publication upon the author’s resubmission of the manuscript).

Select Reviewer

#	Name	Specialization
1	Mohammad Reza Noruzi	EMBA, PhD Student
2	Dr. Badar Alam Iqbal	Ph.D, M.Com, DSW, DBA, AIMA-Accredited Management
3	Ayhan Kapusuzoglu	Ph.D.
4	Shun-Chung Lee	M. Tech
5	Maher Fouad Hossny	Tourism and Hospitality
6	Sangeeta Mohanty	PG Statistics, Ph.D.
7	Dr. Ajay Pal Kaushik	Ph.D.
8	Ashraf Imam	BSc(Hons), PGEDP, MFC
9	Hakimi Abdelaziz	Ph.D.
10	Dr. Jyoti Agarwal	Ph.D. in Commerce P.G. Diploma in Business Management
11	Rakshit Negi	D.Phil. in Commerce/e-Marketing
12	Dr. M. Safdar Rehman	PhD
13	Dr. Wael Elhelece	Ph.D.
14	Wided Mohamed Ragmoun
15	Rishipal	Ph.D., MBA
16	Fakhri Issaqui	Ph.D.
17	Rajnish Aggarwal	MBA Finance
18	Zied Bouaziz	Ph.D.
19	Dodi Irawanto	Ph.D. Cross Cultural Management
20	Dr. Soma Sharma	M.Com, MBA, MIRPM
21	Akmal Shahzad	MS-MGT
22	Ruhizal Roosli	Ph.D. in Housing Studies, ME in Housing Studies
23	Muhammad Zia-ur-Rehman	Ph.D., MBA (HRM), MPM (Project Management), M.A English, M.Ed. (Education)
24	Sajjad	MS Management
25	Associate Professor Dr. Junaid M. Shaikh	PhD,M.Phil; M.Com;B.Com (Hons),GDCA
26	Srividhya Srinivasan	M.com, M.Phil, MBA
27	Ivona Vrdoljak Raguz	Ph.D.
28	Dr. P. Malyadri	M.Com, (HRM), Ph.D.
29	Amir Manzur Wain	M.Phil
30	Nadeem Abbas	MBA
31	Dr. Bhavesh Vanpariya	Ph.D., MBA, PGDRM
32	Agheorghiesei (Corodeanu) Daniela-Tatiana	Associate Professor, PhD.
33	Dr. V. Mahalakshmi	ML, MBA, Ph.D.
34	Yongbing Jiao	Ph.D. Marketing Associate Professor of Marketing
35	Anil Kumar	M.Sc. in Computer Science MBA
36	Dr. Bhawana Bhardwaj	Ph.D. ( Management), UGC-NET, MBA(HRM)
37	Alireza Mamaghani	Ph.D.
38	Dr. Abhilasha Sharma	Ph.D, MBA, B.Sc
39	Dr. Jayasmita Rath	PhD
40	Haruna Issahaku	PhD, Mphil, Bsc.
41	Ashish Agarwal	Ph.D. (IIT DELHI)
42	Nasim Ghanbartehrani	PhD in Industrial Engineering MBA
43	Saleem	MS (HR) MBA
44	Ali Dehghan	PhD
45	Abdul Latif Alhassan	Bsc. Business Administration (Banking and Finance) M.Phil. Business Administration (Risk Management and Insurance)
46	Charles Rarick	Ph.D., Saint Louis University
47	Mounir Belloumi	Ph.D.
48	Dr. G C Mohanta	Bachelors Degree in Mechanical Engineering, Masters Degree in Space Engineering & Rocketry, Masters Degree in Business Administration, PhD in Management Studies
49	Gorze Mitka Iwona	Ph.D.
50	Bratu (Simionescu) Mihaela	PhD in Statistics
51	Iosif Cornel	Economist
52	Ajmer Singh	PhD.
53	Dr. Harry Charles Devasagayam	MSW, MBA, Fellow in Academy of HRD and PhD
54	Dewan Muktadir-Al-Mukit	MBA, BBA (Finance)-University of Dhaka Currently Working as Lecturer in Finance
55	Yenesew Alene	I am Assistant Professor in Tourism and Hospitality
56	Dr. Kapil Jain	PhD M.Phil M Com, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in Management from Institute of Management Studies, Devi Ahilya University, Indore.
57	Naveed Saif	PhD ( HR )
58	Abhishek Kumar	B.Sc., MBA
59	Beenish Ameer	BBA(HONS), MS(FINANCE)
60	Dr. Vikas Gautam	BSC, MBA, MPHIL, PHD
61	Hira Mehmood Abbasi	Masters in Economics and Finance
62	Sabastine Mushori	Lecturer
63	Mansour Esmaeil Zaei	Ph.D. Scholar, Department of Public Administration, Faculty of Arts, Panjab University, Area: Knowledge Management M.A. Public Administration, Major: Change Management, Department of Social Sciences & Economics, Tehran Payeme Noor University (TPNU), IRAN, 2010 B.A. Teaching at Primary School, Isla
64	Dr. Prerna Bamoriya	Ph.D. MBA (MS) B.Com (computer application)
65	Dr. Ramu Nagarajapillai	M.com.,M.Phil.,M.F.M.,PGDBA.,Ph.D
66	Dilip Saikia	M.Phil in Applied Economic, MA
67	Gabariel Dwomoh	Ph.D.
68	Md. Mamunur Rashid	Master of Business Administration in Finance & HRM. Student of M.Phil
69	K. M. Anwarul Islam	Master of Business Administration (MBA), Ph.D.
70	Hossein Niavand	Research Scholar
71	Mohsen Bensalem Br.	Ph.D.
72	Dr. Byram Anand	B.Tech (civil ), MBA ( marketing Management), M.com(general) PGDCA( computers) PDAOR, Ph.D
73	Sulieman Ibraheem Al-hawary	Associate Professor of business Administartion
74	Amir Khazaei	Ph.D.
75	Daniela Roxana Andron	Lecturer, phD in Management, Teacher Training -Economics
76	Aimen Ghaffar	BBA Hons.(Finance) MS (Finance)
77	Abhishek Tiwari	PGDM (honours) (HR & Finance), M.A. (Economics) M.Com , B.Com, C.A. PEE
78	Dr. N Maruti Rao	M.Com.,M.Phil., Ph.D., IIMA-FDP Alumni
79	Sang-Bing Tsai	Editorial board member of Issues in Business Management and Economics (IBME) Editorial board member of Open Journal of Finance Editorial board member of SOP Transactions on Marketing Research
80	Mokhalles Mehdi	Pursuing Ph.D PGDM (International Business with Marketing) BE (Computer Science)
81	Md. Hasebur Rahman	MBA,PhD Fellow
82	Dr. Haitham Hmoud AL Shibly	PhD in Information Systems 2007 School of Design, Communication & Information Technology, University of Newcastle- Australia
83	Alaa Musallam Albkour	Pursuing Ph.D. (Accounting and Finance), from AMU, Aligarh (INDIA).
84	Dr. Yuen Yee Yen	PhD (Management) (Multimedia University Malaysia)
85	Khaliq ur rehman Cheema	PhD Fellow
86	Dr. Jacob M. Nyambe	Dean: Faculty of Economic and Management Sciences, University of Namibia
87	Dr. Anas ALQudah	Assistant Professor Ph.D Financial Management Master Degree Financial Management BA Accounting
88	Dr. Saikat Gochhait	PGDCA,MBA,Msc-IT, PH.D(INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS)-FIMA
89	Prof. Bhavesh Parmar	Ph.D., M.Phil, MBA, BBA
90	Beenish Bashir	MPhil finance
91	Naveed Ahmad S/O Mushtaq Ahmad	MS ( Business Administration )
92	Dr. Gibbet Murambiwa Magaisa	Doctor of Business Administration
93	Valliappan Raju	Associate Professor
94	Leow Chee Seng	MBA, Ph.D
95	Dr. Dheeraj Gandhi	Ph.D,M.B.A,M.A.(Eco.), M.Com,B.Com,
96	Muhammad Israr	Ph.D.
97	Muhammad Hashim	Ph.D.
98	Bhojak Nimesh Pramodkumar	PHD Pursuing in Management, UGC NET Qualified, MBA, BBA
99	Salam Jassim Hmood	PhD Doctor of Philosophy in Business Management, Strategic Management
100	Dr. Srinivas K T	M.Com, Ph.d
101	Lalatendu Kesari Jena	Ph.D.
102	Ravikumar R	B.sc (Agri), MBA (Agribusiness), Ph.D (Agribusiness and Development Management)
103	Mohd Norfian Alifiah	PHD in Business Management (Finance)
104	Uqbah bin Muhammad Iqbal	PhD (History) (February 2012 - Present) - Now waiting for the viva process in June 2015 Master of Business Administration (MBA) (2012) B.Soc.Sc. (Hons) (International Relation) (2008)
105	Allieu Badara Kabia	Bsc. Hons Financial services, MSc. Economics with several certificatioons. Now final year PhD researcher in Economics
106	Adil Zia	PhD in Marketing Management
107	Priyanka P.V	MBA, (PhD in Management), Post Graduate in Advertising and PR and Executive Program for Young Managers.
108	Umar Ijaz Ahmed	PhD
109	Uqbah bin Muhammad Iqbal	PhD in History Master of Business Administration Bachelor in International Relations
110	Sunil Kumar	Ph.D., M.Phil., PGDM and MA
111	Kailaspathi. M. Vishwakarma	M.Com., M.Phil,(Ph.D.)
112	Souhir Neifar	P.h.d Student (P.h.d to be defended in March 2016)
113	Ramzi Trabelsi	Ph.D in economicsMaster in international finance and macroeconomicsBachelor in economics: finance, monney and bank
114	Dr. Gazala Yasmin Ashraf	MBA, PhD
115	Zeba Amjad	M.phil(Economics) Research Continue
116	Fisseha Mengstie	veterinary epidemiologist
117	Emnet Negash Debele	MBA in Busienss Adminstration and Assistant Professor at Jimma Univeristy,Ethiopia
118	Dr. Amit Bijon Dutta	Ph.D, MBA, PG Diploma in Advance Computing,BE(Civil), Diploma in Civil Engineering
119	Avinash Advani	MS in Human Resource Management
120	Neeraj Kumar Sharma	MBA, PGDFT, DME, M.Phil(Management)
121	Dr. Ashutosh Nigam	MBA, MCA Ph.D.(Management)
122	Rudrarup Gupta	B.Com, MBA
123	Samuel Pule	MSc.SCM, MBA (Finance & Accounting), PGD(Project Planning & Management), BSPM
124	Xhavit Islami	Master of Economic Sciences in Management and Informatics
125	Perumalla Varalaxmi	M.COM.,MBA., PH.D
126	Leungo Sigwele	Tourism Marketing/Branding Lecturer
127	Dr. Ashok Kurtkoti	BE. MIE. MMM, PhD
128	Dr. Dinesh Mahajan	M.Com, B.Ed., UGC-NET, Ph.D. (Commerce)
129	Professor Dr. Rer. Pol. Stefan Stackl	Associate Professor of Accounting and Finance
130	Ikrame Selkani
131	Thabit Hassan Thabit	Master in Accounting
132	Mathewos Woldemariam Birru	M.sc. in accounting and finance
133	Amal Farouk Soliman	Assistant Professor - Business Administration
134	Odo Stephen Idenyi	PhD Economics,Diploma Accountancy
135	Gemechu Abdissa	MBA SPECIALIZATION IN FINANCE
136	Bilal Ahmad Pandow	M.Phil MFC
137	Afroditi Anagnostopoulou	PhD in Operations Research
138	Devrshi Upadhayay	B.Com-Accounting and Statistics, M.Com, MBA-Finance, PhD-Finance
139	Ayhan Kuloglu	PhD
140	Tarekegn Tariku	Msc in Accounting & Finance
141	Foram Neel Shah	MBA (Marketing)
142	Md. Nayem Alimul Hyder	LL.B(Hons) LL.M M.S.S in Social Welfare Ph.D in Law
143	Simon Nahusenay Ejigu	Lecturer
144	Mohamed Elheddad	PhD student Economics, third year
145	Richa Aryan	B.COM, M.COM, MBA, Ph.D.
146	Tajalli Fatima	MS management sciences
147	Md. Ashraf Ali	BBA (Major in Finance and Banking), MBA (Major in Finance and Banking)
148	Shahriar Daudpota	MSc. HRD & Consultancy
149	Ioan-Bogdan Robu	Lecturer, PhD in Accounting and PhD Candidate in Statistics
150	Sirajuddin Omsa	Doctorate
151	Ramel D. Tomaquin, Ph.D.	Ph.D. in Philippine Studies and Doctor in Public Administration ( Ph.D., DPA).
152	Anshika Bansal
153	Mohammod Naymur Rahman	BBA, MBA, Jagannath University
154	Amir Ahmad Dar	Ph.D
155	Apurva Bhatnagar	MHRM , PhD ( Pursuing)
156	Ali Ahmadi
157	Alesia Nichols	Results-driven, personable leader with 25 years extensive experience managing recruiting, hiring, negotiating and strategic/succession planning within highgrowth, evolving banking, retail and energy environments. Able to lead and direct changes in HR delivery throughout all levels of an organizati
158	Dr. (Mrs.) Chinyere Samuel Ecoma	NCE, B.A. (Hons.) Education History, M.A. African History, Ph.D History
159	Bettina Mrusek	Ph.D. in Business Administration from Northcentral University
160	Marcelo Amaral Dionisio	PHD Student
161	Jung Lang Cheng	Associate Professor
162	Abdullah Mohammad Al-zoubi	PH-D Accounting Professor Assestence
163	Aderibigbe Oluwagbemiga Abiodun	B.sc (Hon.) Library and Information Sciences Masters in Library and Information Sciences (M.sc) PhD (In view)
164	Witness Maluleke	Doctor Technogiae: Policing
165	Mohamednour Eltahir Ahmed	Phd
166	Dr. Jan Mohammad	PhD
167	Ranitha Weerarathna	* Master of Business Administration- University of Sunderland Postgraduate Diploma in Business Management programme, completed at ICBT Campus, Sri Lanka Master in Labour Relations and Human Resource Management University of Colombo- (2015-2016) Coursework completed * Bachelor of Business Ma
168	Umer Jeelanie Banday	(Ph.D Economics), Hub Scientist (Economics) IITD, India
169	Michael Jordan Bianchi	Michael Bianchi holds a degree in Chemical Engineering with a Masters degree in Project Management and Product Development in Production Engineering from the School of Engineering of So Carlos, University of So Paulo. His work focused on the development of a tool for hybrid project management
170	Dr. Onkar Nath Mishra
171	Dr. Chintala Balaji	Ph.D, M.Phil, M.B.A, B.Sc, Assistant Professor, KL Business School, KLEF, GUNTUR, INDIA.
172	Francesco Agliata	Assistant professor in Accounting and business administration
173	Sanjib Biswas	B.Tech (Electronics & Telecommunication Engineering) MBA (Operations Management) PhD (Pursuing - Operations Research)
174	Mukesh Garg	PhD
175	Dr. Hardeep Kaur	PhD in Business Studies
176	Richard Wamalwa Wanzala	PhD Finance
177	Okello john Paul	PhD candidate Finance. MBA Finance, BA-Economics
178	Prof. P. Rathnaswamy	PhD (Law), PhD (Mgt) , DLitt (Mgt) MCom, LLB, LLM, PG Dip (UK)
179	Chokri Aloui	Ph.D in Economics, Sousse University, Tunisia.
180	Hossein Moghimi Esfandabadi
181	Jeremy Bennett	PhD
182	Ignacio Sariego Lopez	PhD.
183	Sergej Gricar	Econometrics, Hospitality industry management
184	Poongothai Selvarajan	PhD in ManagementMaster of Business AdminisrationBachelor of Business Administration
185	Ramprabha K	B.E., MBA., Ph.D
186	Dr. R. Satheeshkumar	Ph.D
187	Atena Mirhosseini Vakili
188	Nigel Raylyn DSilva	PhD (Econometrics), MBA (International Business), BSc. (Statistics), FDP (IIM- Ahmedabad), Certificate course in Computer Programming (NMIMS)
189	Gulimzhan Suleimenova	Economist
190	Avijit Mallik	B.Sc in Mechanical Engineering
191	Hillary Odor	B.Sc Master of Business Administration (MBA) M.Sc Business Administration (Organisational Behaviour) PhD Business Administration (Organisational Behaviour) in view.
192	Nurul Mohammad Zayed	MS in Economics Major : International Economics Year of Passing : 2014 Name of Institution : North South University Result : CGPA 3.23 (In the Scale of 4.00) Master of Business Administration (MBA) Major : Finance Year of Passing : 2009 Name of Institution : Eas
193	Dr. S Gokula Krishnan	MBA., PGDHRM., PhD.,
194	Anam Bhatti	MBA ( Marketing) University of Sargodha Pakistan PhD scholar Universiti Utara Malaysia
195	Alamgir Hossain	Lecturer
196	Hasanuzzaman Tushar	Ph.D. Candidate MBA
197	Desalegn Tesfaw Abate	MBA in Business Administration BA in Marketing and Sales Management
198	Zeinab Zaremohzzabieh	Postdoctoral Fellow
199	Shwetank Avikal	ASSISTANT PROFESSOR
200	Dr. Arindam Banerjee	Assistant Professor
201	Serge Messomo Elle	Professor
202	Fatima Zohra Abousaid	PH.D. STUDENT IN MANAGEMENT SCIENCE
203	Dr. Khawaja Jehanzeb	Lecturer
204	Waqar Khalid	PhD Research Scholar
205	Elmelki Anas	Dr in Finance Assistant Professor in Gafsa University and Dean of higher institute of Arts and Crafts Gafsa University Tunisia
206	Moetaz Soubjaki
207	Elias Haruni Mseti	Lecturer
208	Hewa kumbalgoda Gamage Sriyani Ranasinghe	Lecturer
209	wael omran aly
210	Arshad Bhat	Post-Doctoral Research Associate
211	Des Raj	PROFESSOR
212	Mustafa Ozer	Professor in Economics and Econometrics
213	Nadia Mansour	Doctor in finance, lecturer, finance and management researcher university,fellow member of Global Journals
214	Dr. Ity Patni	Associate Professor, Department of Business Administration, Manipal University Jaipur, India
215	Afizan Bin Amer	Senior Lecturer
216	Issa Mohd Hemed	Lecturer
217	BENDEHIBA Mohamed	Algeria
218	TRIPON CRISTINA	PhD Assistent Lecturer
219	Sabari Rajan G B	Associate Professor
220	Aloysius Rukundo	Lecturer
221	Farian Tahrim	Researcher
222	Mutasem Mahmoud Jaloudi	PhD
223	Iboro E. Nelson	Ph.D Economics (Development/Health Options)
224	Dennis Murega	Administrator
225	Shahul Hameed.K	Director
226	Robert Douglas Waldo	Associate Professor
227	Nor Zafir Md Salleh	Senior Lecturer
228	ESAKKIMUTHU	Ph.D. Research scholar
229	VIKAS KUMAR	ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, UNIVERSITY BUSINESS SCHOOL, GURU NANAK DEV UNIVERSITY, AMRITSAR (PUNJAB) INDIA
230	Dr. Raju Rosha	Assistant Professor
231	Chartaya Nilplub	PhD. in Management
232	Dr. Palkesh Soni	PhD, MBA
233	Laxmi Wadhwani	Ph.D
234	Suyog Dixit
235	Dr Muttappa Bagali	Head-MBA; Professor of Management and Human Resources
236	suat Akyürek	PhD candidate and lecturer
237	Dr. J. Jose Prabhu	Research Associate & Visiting Professor
238	N.SHAIK MOHAMED	ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR OF COMMERCE
239	Demis Hailegebreal Hailu	PhD candidate, Lecturer
240	Cristiane Aparecida da Silva	Reviewer
241	Pritesh Chitrode
242	GAUTAMKUMAR PARASOTAMBHAI KANANI	ASSISTANT PROFESSOR
243	Isaac Tandoh	A professor of management and communications at the Central university business school, Kumasi, campus, Ghana.
244	Ansar Abbas	Banking Officer
245	Neetu Mahendru	Assistant Professor at GNA University ,Phagwara
246	SIMRANJEET SINGH	ASSISTANT PROFESSOR IN COMMERCE AND MANAGEMENT
247	Md. Mokshud Ali	Former Assistant Professor Faculty of Business Administration University of Science and Technology Chittagong (USTC), Bangladesh.
248	Dr.Rajesh Rengaswamy	Associate Professor and Head, Department of Commerce (Information Technology), Department of Commerce (Banking & Insurance), Hindusthan College of Art and Science (Autonomous), Coimbatore - 641 028 India
249	Dr.Gajendra Naidu jatty	Prof & HOD
250	bajrang lal	Researcher
251	Dr. Harpreet Kaur	Assistant Professor
252	Dr.J.Gajendra Naidu	Prof&HOD Faculty Business and Accounting Botho university Gaborone Botswana
253	MD SULIMAN HOSSIN	Lecturer
254	Venketesh Iyer	Head of Analytics, Business Planning and Operations at Facebook. Sales Operations, and Go-To-Market Planning leader. B.E., M.S., M.B.A
255	Dr.Nandita Mishra	Associate Professor
256	Cândido J. Peres M.
257	Marco Bevolo	Founder, Marco Bevolo Consulting
258	TIMBA GAELLE TATIANA	Dr
259	Mauricio Azálgara Bedoya	Mister / Sir
260	Jonathan Mukiza Peter Kansheba	PhD-Fellow (International Business)-UiA, Kristiansand-Norway. Lecturer-Department of Business Studies-ARU,Dar Es Salaam,Tanzania
261	Ernest Ofori Asamoah	Professor of Management
262	Silvia Helena Carvalho Ramos valladao de Camargo
263	Dr. Shilpa Bahl	Associate Professor
264	zied bouaziz	assistant professor in accounting at the Higher Institute of Management of Gabes
265	Vitalii Nitsenko	Pr. Dr.
266	Daniel Oigo Ogachi	Lecturer
267	Şeyma Güner
268	Syafrida Hafni Sahir	Associated Professor
269	Md. Mobarak Hossain	PhD Candidate in Econometrics and Quantitative Economics
270	DR. SOURABH JAIN	ASSISTANT PROFESSOR
271	Ghada Abdalla Mohamed	Professor
272	Dr Chitra	Professor
273	Jayasuriya Arachchillage Prasansha Kumari	Senior Lecturer I (Dr)
274	Mubinzhon Abduvaliev
275	Abdur Rakib Nayeem	Lecturer
276	Bhavna Sharma	Assistant Professor
277	Dr.K.A.Keerthi Prabu	Assistant Professor Department of Economics V.O.Chidambaram College Tuticorin
278	Dr. Salah Ahmed Oraby	Major specialization is Accounting Accurate specialization is Managerial and cost accounting
279	RACHAEL WAMBUI MWANGI-GITONGA	Ph.D. student
280	Abobakr Aljuwaiber
281	Dr. Arshed Fouad Altameemi	Finance and Banking
282	Dr. Ronoh Kipronoh Paul	Director Programmes and Standards
283	fatma alahouel	PhD in Finance
284	Dr Hari Lal Bhaskar	Assistant Professor
285	Prof.N.V.Suresh	Head of the Department Department of Management Studies Remo International College
286	Prof. (Dr.) Paresh Shah	Principal and Professor, Rai Business School, Rai University, Ahmedabad 380014 INDIA
287	Chiselebwe Ngandwe	Dr.
288	Dr.Aarti Sharma	Assistant professor
289	Dr. Mani Jindal	Assistant Professor
290	Dr Neha Vashistha	Assistant Professor, School of Business Studies, Shobhit Insitute of Engineering & Technology (Deemed to be University)
291	Dr. Sajjad Ahmad Parry	Assistant Professor
292	Dr. Danstun Ngonyani	Lecturer
293	Dr Sarita Mishra	Assistant Professor, Sri Sri University, Cuttack
294	Walid Ibrahim Hassan Ibrahim	Dr. Walid Hassan
295	Viktor Oliinyk	Professor, Department of Economic Cybernetics
296	Omer Allagabo Omer Mustafa	Dr
297	DES RAJ	PROFESSOR
298	Dr Rami Ibrahim A. Salem	Reviewer
299	Murray John Bryant	Professor Emeritus, Western University, Ontario, CANADA PhD, Master of Commerce, MA, CA (Australia and New Zealand)
300	Dr. Meenakshi Sharma	Assistant Professor
301	RAJESWARA RAO K V S	ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR
302	Diaconescu Luca
303	Dr. Anshu Choudhary	Associate Professor
304	Sara Escudero García
305	Dr. Kunal Sil	Post Doctoral Fellow in Commerce
306	Ihab Alagha
307	Dr. Anshu Choudhary	Associate Professor
308	Miloš Krstić	Research Associate Faculty of Sciences and Mathematics Department of Mathematics
309	Katerina Fotova Čiković	Lecturer at the Department of Business and Management
310	VBNH Saroja Achanta	visiting faculty
311	María Isabel Sánchez Pazmiño	PdD(c)
312	Theophilus Tebetso Tshukudu	Dcotor of Human Resource Lecturer
313	Erginbay Uğurlu
314	Zdeněk Mikoláš	Mr., prof., prof. h. c., Ing., PhD.
315	Abin George	Technical Officer
316	Bing Zhu
317	Donn Enrique L. Moreno	Program Coordinator of Bachelor of Science in Entrepreneurship and Bachelor of Science in Business Administration Major in Marketing Management
318	Dejan Dašić	PhD
319	Dr Maroua Ben Maaouia	Assistant Professor
320	Samuel Tabot Enow
321	Dr. Benson Kunjukunju	Professor
322	Ambreeen Goni	Doctor
323	Dr. Muhammad Fareed	International Senior Lecturer
324	Aloka Shashinath Karunasingha	Research Supervisor BMS(Hons) Degree Programme
325	Suadat Hussain Wani	Post-Doctoral Fellow
326	Dr VijayaKumar Thota	Assistant Professor (Sr. Grade II)
327	Hang Nguyen Thi	Head of section
328	Dr. Raja Kamal Ch	Assistant Professor
329	Ayodeji Michael Obadire	Senior Lecturer
330	Promise Maduako	MSc Health Technology BTech Prosthetics and Orthotics Technology
331	Mahmoudou SOW
332	Francis Daka
333	NKUNDABARAMYE Vincent
334	María Gabriela Torres Suárez
335	A. K. Mahbubul Hye	Lecturer
336	Eunyoung Jang	Assistant Professor of Marketing, Midwestern State University
337	Paul Singh	Research Professor Da Vinci Business School Johannesburg South Africa
338	Margarita Gil-Jerez	PhD in training
339	Fikru Kefyalew Alemayehu
340	Shadreck Muchaku	Post-doctoral fellow
341	Dr. Julie Fisher Melton	poliical scientist, specialist on civil society and democratization
342	Godwin Banafo Akrong
343	Richard Seow Yeaw Chong	DBA candidate
344	Victor Kilanko
345	Yang Immanuel Pachankis
346	Dr. William Brent Felstead	PhD
347	Aslinda Mohd Shahril	Associate Professor
348	Ramadas Kandath	Senior Business Process consultant
349	Surendra Reddy Challapalli	VP technology, Author, Mentor, Jury panel member for Industry Awards.
350	Walter Nhundu	Group Finance& Operations Manager
351	Haici Zhang
352	Yayoi Hirose	Professor in business, Toyo University, Japan
353	LYDIA CHERUTO PKAREMBA	LECTURER- ECONOMICS
354	Panagiotis Tzavaras	Panagiotis E. Tzavaras, PhD
355	CHEN KAIYUE
356	Ahmed Mohamed Habib	BSc, MSc, PhD, DBA
357	Hari Prasad Josyula	Senior Product Manager
358	Daniel Nascimento-e-Silva	Professor and Researcher at the Federal Institute of Education, Science and Technology of Amazonas, Brazil
359	ANDREA BELEN ARDITI	PhD candidate in Management. Full professor of National University of the Center of the Buenos Aires Province, Argentina.
360	Leenshya GUNNOO	Lecturer
361	Bachchu Kailash Kaini	Sr. Lecturer of Healthcare Management and Leadership, Anglia Ruskin University, UK

Assessment Sheet

SECTION A

How would you rate paper overall ?

SECTION B

The Theme

As per your Section A rating and numerous other parameters we have used Artificial Intelligence to determine ratings for Section B. You may change them as per your analysis.

SECTION B.1

Integrity & Analysis of the Theme

How impactful is this Theme

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION B.1.1

Theme Analysis and Exploration

How author has analyzed and, explored the theme of the research?

SECTION B.1.2

Concept originality/Breakthrough

This does NOT refer to Plagiarism. This means how much enhanced in field author has made with respect to the previous referenced research

SECTION B.1.3

Presented Concept

This measures how much sufficiently novel is the article and has added new knowledge to the stream

SECTION B.1.4

How fundamental the concept is?

HHow close the concept is to the fundamental foundation or basis of the corresponding research in the stream? Given more mark if it is more fundamental.

SECTION B.1.5

Depth of the Research

The depth of theme and research work

SECTION B.1.6

The scope of stream

How is the article related to the scope of the stream?

SECTION B.1.7

Meaningful interpretation of the results

How logically has the author interpreted the results of the study

SECTION B.1.8

Logical Conclusions

Were any logical conclusions made by the author?

SECTION B.1.9

Relevance of the Article

How relevant is the research topic is with respect to the current needs in the stream ?

SECTION B.2

Extensibility of Research

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION B.2.1

Flexibility of Theory

The consistency of the conclusion with respect to the theory

SECTION B.2.2

Future aspects of Research

Whether the research topic is a hot topic of its stream

SECTION B.2.3

Flexibility of input data

If the results are consistent even if the input data is changed

SECTION B.3

Applications of Research

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION B.3.1

Direct impact of the research to industries

How much the research impacts directly to the industries for their betterment

SECTION B.3.2

Applications to interdisciplinary streams

How much is the research useful for multiple streams

SECTION B.3.3

Compatibility with local laws

It should not break any local laws, take US laws if unknown

SECTION C

Structural and Compilation Gradation of Article

Formatting is publisher's job, evaluation of the following is not based on the layout of the article.

SECTION C.1

Interactivity

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.1.1

Proper headings

How author has analyzed and explored theme of the research?

SECTION C.1.2

Figures and Photographs

Relevance of theme and no figure should lack captions

SECTION C.1.3

Charts and Tables

Properly and nicely formatted

SECTION C.1.4

High resolution of images

More than 600 DPI (Dot Per Inch). Means graphics must not be blurry

SECTION C.1.5

Aspect Ratio

The ratio of the width to the height of an image must be correct

SECTION C.1.6

Vector images in case of illustrative figures

If figures are not photographs, they must be in vector format

SECTION C.2

Title, Abstract and Keywords

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.2.1

Title

The title of the paper effectively frames the study

SECTION C.2.2

Contains specific data

It should be relevant and summary of whole article

SECTION C.2.3

Single paragraph

It should be only of single paragraph

SECTION C.2.4

250 words or less

250 words or less are considered better

SECTION C.2.5

Grammar and spelling

Scientific terminologies used are correct and consistent

SECTION C.2.6

Clear and concise

It should have good readability

SECTION C.2.7

Translated to English

Title, abstract and keywords should be in English also even if the article is non-English.

SECTION C.2.8

Keywords

Keywords should be used correctly and consistently

SECTION C.3

Introduction Section

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.3.1

Background

Background and history of the topic should be well summarized

SECTION C.3.2

Appropriate depth

It should go into the proper details

SECTION C.3.3

Goal clearly stated

What a reader should expect from the article should also be stated

SECTION C.3.4

References cited

Reference in standard format like APA

SECTION C.3.5

Transition and flow

Content in introduction should be connecting, logical, clear, easy to follow

SECTION C.3.6

Grammar and spelling

Semantic report is sent separately, still you can judge

SECTION C.3.7

Sentence/paragraph structure

Subheadings in Introduction Section

SECTION C.4

Material & Methods Section

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.4.1

Complete and Detailed

Method specified should be reproducible

SECTION C.4.2

Reference cited

References are given in a standard style. For example, APA

SECTION C.4.3

Correct format

Method should be well structured

SECTION C.4.4

Grammar and Spelling

Thorough semantic report is sent separately, still this parameter is judged

SECTION C.4.5

Sentence/paragraph structure

Separate subsections for material and procedure

SECTION C.5

Article Content

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.5.1

Appropriate length

Length of the article should neither be to long nor too short depending on the type of article (review/original)

SECTION C.5.2

Reference cited

References are given in a standard style in the whole article. For example, APA

SECTION C.5.3

Transition and flow

Article's contents should be connecting, logical, clear, easy to follow

SECTION C.5.4

Grammar and Spelling

Thorough semantic report is sent separately, still this parameter is judged for the whole article

SECTION C.5.5

Sentence/paragraph structure

Proper structure of the whole article

SECTION C.6

Results Section

If results section is not required, mark NR

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.6.1

Well organized results

Presentation of results section

SECTION C.6.2

Clear and concise

It should have good readability

SECTION C.6.3

Accuracy of results in prima facie

If result data looks correct

SECTION C.6.4

Standalone readability

Can anyone read results section without reading whole article ?

SECTION C.6.5

Grammar and Spelling

Semantic report is sent separately, still you can judge

SECTION C.6.6

Sentence/paragraph structure

Separate subsections for material and procedure

SECTION C.7

Discussion/Conclusion Section

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.7.1

Overall discussion

Conclusion, merits and demerits of the research should be clearly stated

SECTION C.7.2

Integration with theory

How is the conclusion related to the theory presented in the article

SECTION C.7.3

References cited in the comments section

Reference in standard format like APA

SECTION C.7.4

Concise and appropriate

Authors arrived at clear, well-supported and evidence-based conclusions

SECTION C.7.5

Logical conclusions

Conclusion deduced should be logically correct and obvious

SECTION C.7.6

Grammar and spelling

Thorough semantic report is sent separately, still this parameter is judged for the conclusion section

SECTION C.7.7

Dissenting arguments scope

Better if variance of expressed opinions with the tradition is high

SECTION C.7.8

Acknowledgements

Acknowledgement and conflict of interest should be stated

SECTION C.7.9

References/Bibliography

Literature Cited section should have complete citation information in standard format

SECTION C.8

To be Filled by Reviewer

SHOW DETAILS

SECTION C.8.1

Number of Authors

Less score when more than 5 authors

SECTION C.8.2

Author's credibility

To be judged by Editors

SECTION C.8.3

Corresponding author's country's contribution to research

Directly calculated by System

SECTION D

Comment and Recommendation

SECTION D.1

Comment

SECTION D.2

Your Recommendation

Publish As It Is (The article fulfills all of the requirements listed above and is ready for publication).

Minor Revision. (The article contains a small number of easily correctable errors including grammar, missing references, and minor content clarification).

Major Revision. (The article has significant deficiencies in content and grammar).

Not Suitable for Publication. (The article is not suitable for publication).